Beth's was romantic and tragic, capturing the Romeo-and-Juliet-esque story right down to the end. It was beautiful and graceful, even with the mistake at the end.
Matt's on the other hand was certainly more contemporary, but the way he loomed over Brianne, hardly looked at her and made it look all about himself... The only "story" I could take from it was maybe it was an abusive relationship and the end was a murder suicide? He's a great skater when it's his style, but not very adaptable...
tl;dr: Beth's was my favourite