Originally Posted by MrRen:
“Think next year will almost certainly be the last!”
I think it is obvious now that the series is past its halcion days, although to be fair, it still pulls in a solid 6.5 Million for the main show and thats not to be sniffed at.
Over the past few years, many changes have been made both to the Judging Panel and to the format and look of the show to no avail as Viewing Figures have continued to steadily drop to a level that no longer shows it as "Event Television"
DOI was always some way behind SCD in terms of attracting big celebrities and always felt, to me anyway, like SCD's cheaper cousin. Perhaps it fails to attract a better class of celebrity because of the risk factor involved and as most of the celebrities taking part in DOI are generally unemployed, they can risk breaking a leg as opposed to those on SCD, who are more likely to be in work as they are generally of a higher calibre.
With regard to the Host's....The Philip Schofield that I grew up with is not the Philip Schofield that I now see hosting DOI....he was moulded into another ITV puppet and slowly became full of himself, cocky, arrogant and way too self important. This upsets me as I used to love him on CBBC and Test The Nation.
Christine Bleakley, despite my personal feelings on her departure from the BBC, is quite a competent Television host but for some reason, just looks somewhat uncomfortable presenting DOI with Pip and to my mind that partnership never really gelled. The presenting duties she has held with ITV since her move in 2010 certainly do not justify the very large contract she was given and it is blatently obvious that ITV offered her the DOI role so as to try and justify her value. For me, she doesnt work on DOI and therefore should be replaced.
Chris and Jane. Both are the show's most valuable asset and are criminally underused. They should be given a more expanded creative role and more screen time. The decision on which contestant to eliminate each week should be given to them, not the main judges.
Judges...Karen should be removed from the Judging Panel as she is biased towards all those who compete and can therefore, not be constructive or critical enough, she always lets her emotions cloud her judgement and for these reasons should not be a judge.
Robin - Happy for him to continue in his current Head Judge role.
Jason - Generally performed better this series and, apart from the usual bout of nastiness every now and again, I would be happy for him to stay.
Ashley - Still do not understand why she was chosen to judge, is it from a performance point of view that her opinion counts? because if it is, both Robin and Jason can quite easily critique in this area. She is actually very good but would be much more suited to X Factor or The Voice as a judge in her own genre.
I believe Katerina should be brought back to replace Karen and another professional brought in to replace Ashley or perhaps revert back to 3 Judges?
Live Music/Orchestra should be introduced to replace the recorded tracks and a larger ice rink for improved group show numbers with Chris and Jane with a warmer more colourful set. Presently, it looks too cold and unwelcoming.
Just my humble opinion.

A move back to Saturday for the main show would be a good move in my opinion.