Not only does tonight's result make the judges look stupid, but surely even more stupid for saving Matt over Shane in the skate off a few weeks back. Shayne was just improving at that point and IMO did a better skate off than Matt.

Thoughts?
Last edited by Captain Birdsei : 10-03-2013 at 23:57

Even Jason would have sent him home, that says it all, he was the only one who had the balls to make that particular call and I agreed with him.

They sent Pamela home when she tripped, the most expensive contestant in the series but kept Matt when he made a similar error.

He couldn't even blame his tits.

Shayne was improving all the time. And I know this has been done to death but Matt should have gone after that fall in the SO.

It was the one week I agreed with Jason, despite differing levels of ability a clean skate is a clean skate. Matt did well tonight but has been in the bottom two before, as would Shayne have been. I don't think it would have made much difference against Beth who was never in one and therefore had plenty of voters behind her.

No. Despite the mistake, Matt's routine was far superior in both content and skating, therefore he deserved to be saved over Shayne.

Agreed & I'm not a massive Matt fan. He was easily better than Shayne despite his fall.

Funny now that a few weeks ago Jason was adamant that the other judges made the wrong decision & now he is acting like a spoilt child cos Matt didn't win