• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • TV Shows: Reality
  • Past Reality Shows
  • Dancing On Ice: All Stars
The controversy over the final result
<<
<
3 of 3
>>
>
BillyBoy7
12-03-2013
Originally Posted by tilly07:
“I think regardless of the reason people voted for Beth, whether it was because they're a gymnast, a Dan fan or just thought she was good, she deserved every vote she got. There was no showmance or sob stories along the way. She came across as a positive professional polite young lady. There were no tantrums or tears. She worked hard training, took criticism on the chin and improved every week. Her parents should be very proud of her. Matt Lapinskas could learn a thing or two from Beth!”

Agree with every word.
Tall Paul
12-03-2013
Also Beth didn't have an unfair advantage of having some sort of ice dance training wheras matt did blatently. In actual fact a few routines he did lacked balance on a few occasions so yet the judges overlooked them. I do get the impression that with one or two judges that their heart really isn't in for doing DOI at all, Jason I think has blown his second chance and there's no way Karen can coach and judge at the same time. As well as that I think at times she hasn't looked all that well and tired really doing two jobs.

To be fair the judges were wrong to act like spoilt kids, but Beth is a very strong character so she can let it wash over her. Judges and production have taken the piss this year they really have.
SimonChimp
12-03-2013
It's quite ironic that people claim Beth won because it's a personality contest but also claim she has no personality
unknownstuntman
12-03-2013
I'll be honest, I stopped watching this series because of the blatant fawning over and pushing to the public of Matt's greatness....

I watched the final after reading about this controversy over Beth winning.
Well, there isn't one lol, best skater won (since when has the Bolero had hip hop body popping moves in it???)

The judges faces... jeez. Polite and nice or what (and even Philip Schofield never offered Beth a hug or kiss from the footage I saw)

I can't see why they got rid of Katarina for Karen (other than the obvious reasons lol) I had been dreading Louis Spence as a judge but found him really rather good. Bring them both back, get rid of Karen and Jason and get rid of Robin too. (Bring back Nicky)

The Twitter comments from certain 'professionals' is staggering. Do they not think before posting? lol
davedub
12-03-2013
Originally Posted by goldberry1:
“I've just watched the Dancing On Ice Final again - Matt and Brianne were absolutely brilliant - they were robbed. Beth and her partner were good but for excitement and flare Matt and Brianne were the best.”

I agree, love beth but matt was outstanding
Cranberryapple
12-03-2013
Originally Posted by goldberry1:
“Being the publics favourites doesn't mean Beth and her partner were the best - Matt and Brianne were best and were robbed of the title. Beth was boring.”

Of course it does. The Public made them the winners

Matt should've signed up for Ice Hockey
pothuthic
12-03-2013
Jason just tweeted "@officialJasonG: For those who have given me shit for my glum face on the final, I received very sad news that my grandfather was critical ill in hospital."
biggle2000
12-03-2013
Originally Posted by Cranberryapple:
“Of course it does. The Public made them the winners

Matt should've signed up for Ice Hockey”

Maybe he'd be ok it there was a bodypopping on ice series
hitnmix
12-03-2013
Originally Posted by pothuthic:
“Jason just tweeted "@officialJasonG: For those who have given me shit for my glum face on the final, I received very sad news that my grandfather was critical ill in hospital."”

If it is true that he got the news about his Grandfather at that very moment then yes I could understand why he looked like that. But lets not forget he was happy as Larry when gushing all over Matt so if he had got the news before the show there is no excuse.

Anyway this does not excuse the other judges and their lack of professionalism
Tiggergirl
12-03-2013
Originally Posted by pothuthic:
“Jason just tweeted "@officialJasonG: For those who have given me shit for my glum face on the final, I received very sad news that my grandfather was critical ill in hospital."”

Not saying its not true but I find it a bit suspicious. He was lively enough telling Matt he was his champion in the segment before and had been lively enough throughout the show even being rather animated on occasions. I can't somehow see the news being broken to him in the middle of the show and it just seems rather coincedental that his face like a sour lemon just happened to occur when Beth was announced winner.

It could just be that he found out just that second but I think he is now just trying to cover his back in the face of all the public outcry against all the judges so he comes out looking not as bad the whole "I had a reason to look miserable so don't moan at me"

I may be cynical but I don't buy it.
Tall Paul
12-03-2013
Originally Posted by pothuthic:
“Jason just tweeted "@officialJasonG: For those who have given me shit for my glum face on the final, I received very sad news that my grandfather was critical ill in hospital."”

So his judgement was clouded then, if it would have been Craig revel Horwood he would have pushed it aside. Still don't condone Jason's bias, he has been dreadful this season.
unknownstuntman
12-03-2013
Originally Posted by hitnmix:
“If it is true that he got the news about his Grandfather at that very moment then yes I could understand why he looked like that. But lets not forget he was happy as Larry when gushing all over Matt so if he had got the news before the show there is no excuse.

Anyway this does not excuse the other judges and their lack of professionalism”

Was just going to say everything you have. He wasn't glum when fawning over Matt being his champion. And the other 3 have no excuse (or they've not tweeted them yet)

Sorry if his granddad is ill, but if he got the news before the show, he shouldn't have gone on. Otherwise, it was very unfortunate/convenient timing when he got the news.
Tall Paul
12-03-2013
Originally Posted by unknownstuntman:
“I'll be honest, I stopped watching this series because of the blatant fawning over and pushing to the public of Matt's greatness....

I watched the final after reading about this controversy over Beth winning.
Well, there isn't one lol, best skater won (since when has the Bolero had hip hop body popping moves in it???)

The judges faces... jeez. Polite and nice or what (and even Philip Schofield never offered Beth a hug or kiss from the footage I saw)

I can't see why they got rid of Katarina for Karen (other than the obvious reasons lol) I had been dreading Louis Spence as a judge but found him really rather good. Bring them both back, get rid of Karen and Jason and get rid of Robin too. (Bring back Nicky)

The Twitter comments from certain 'professionals' is staggering. Do they not think before posting? lol”

I agree as its evidence that the judges don't think what most of us think anymore and with the producers have alienated us. To be honest we are free to blast the way the judges have been like. They really have said some very silly things this year and have had the backlash they've deserved.
conchie
12-03-2013
How can the result be controversial. Two skaters come out... they skate.. the public votes.. the one with the most votes wins ... SIMPLES !! Even Jason tweeted earlier that day the same message.. saying the winner will be the one with the most votes. If anything was controversial it was how the judges reacted.... it was disgraceful.
pothuthic
12-03-2013
Jason's been the best judge this series by miles, his decisions have always been right iirc
Tall Paul
12-03-2013
Originally Posted by conchie:
“How can the result be controversial. Two skaters come out... they skate.. the public votes.. the one with the most votes wins ... SIMPLES !! Even Jason tweeted earlier that day the same message.. saying the winner will be the one with the most votes. If anything was controversial it was how the judges reacted.... it was disgraceful.”

Goes to show how greedy the judges were in that case, they've shown themselves up by not being transparent with the viewer.
Ignazio
12-03-2013
Originally Posted by pothuthic:
“Jason just tweeted "@officialJasonG: For those who have given me shit for my glum face on the final, I received very sad news that my grandfather was critical ill in hospital."”

So that's why he rolled his eyes?
kaycee
12-03-2013
I fail to see the "controversy" over the final result.

All 4 judges were of one opinion; the majority of the voting viewers were of another. Simples & end of!
<<
<
3 of 3
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map