[FernandoM]

She is wacky and spontaneous, yet her critiques on American Idol and X Factor USA were generally sound.

In the 90s, she sold millions of records and cemented her name as one of the best dancers/choreographers.

She certainly would be a lot more interesting than some of the current judges. What do you think?

[InMyArms]

Interesting, I think i'd quite like it.

[Zack06]

Nicole and Paula on the same panel is not a good idea imo. If Nicole wasn't coming back then I think she could work on the panel, but not otherwise. She was good as a guest judge in 2006.

[PJ River]

I love Paula Abdul but she was as bad a coach as Demi Lovato.

[jackbell]

I feel more sorry for her that she was dumped after one series of XF US than Cheryl or Nicole. I think she was far worse treated than either - especially. as she and Simon go back a lot further.

There has not been a peep from her since - Cheryl and Nicole have bounced back, but not Paula. Shame. Hope she's in a good place.

[staceyxxx23]

I'd love this! She's my favourite female judge of all time on any show.

[InMyArms]

Originally Posted by PJ River

I love Paula Abdul but she was as bad a coach as Demi Lovato.

That's not fair, she put a huge amount of effort into her groups that year. She had a very poor category from the beginning, not helped by Simon (a producer!) manipulating the show to favour his contestants.

[CinnamonBrick]

Nah, definitely not.
It didn't work with Nicole and Paula on the same panel, doubt it'll work again.

[fireemblemcraze]

NO! Definitely not. I don't know why people like the bland judges so much like Dannii, Paula. They just infuriate me. They possess nothing of interest to the panel. No form of entertainment that I would enjoy. Not to mention I cringe at every joke they both make.

[87Ben]

Paula was better off on American Idol. I didnt like her on the X Factor USA