Originally Posted by Christian Cage:
“No it did not come down to the freestyle IMO. Kellie has a bigger fanbase than Zendaya and TPTB knew it that's why they gave her to Derek.”
I actually disagree. Not only did Zendaya win all the previous twitter votes, such as Homecoming Queen and prior Encore, but if you compared the YouTube views for their dances, in the early weeks of the competition Zendaya's dances sometimes had 2 or even 3 times the views Kellie's did. I noticed about two weeks ago that Kellie sometimes overtook Zendaya in total views, though I made no effort to determine how much earlier that occurred.
The first indication that Kellie's freestyle struck a chord with viewers, and that Kellie might win, was when I saw the YouTube views for Kelly's freestyle on one YT channel were something like 56,000 for Kellie and around 5,000 for Zendaya's freestyle. On Tuesday it was about 109,000 to 13,000. Right now it's 181,479 to 27,022 in Kellie's favor on one YT channel and 107,443 to 24,806 on another.
Zendaya has almost 2 million more twitter followers than Kellie and 1.5 million more than Derek and Kellie combined. Right now, on one channel, the YT views of Zendaya's trio are nearly double those of Kellie's trio: 118,724 to 60,224, while Kellie's Samba has nearly 3 times the views of Zendaya's Paso Doble, 97,247 to 34,894; Kellie's AT has 71,049 to Z's QS (39,909), while Z's Samba has more views at 97,247 than Kellie's Paso, 34,894.
In all of those cases, the views aren't predictable, but seem to depend very much on the particular dance. From the above stats, you could say viewers would rather see a good Samba than a Paso Doble. And I've seen many anecdotal comments saying someone was originally for X, but switched to Y, and Kellie was often mentioned, both ways.
I think the conclusion is inescapable that Zendaya has tons of fans but that viewers were more moved by Kellie's freestyle. Once again the freestyle won the competition.