Simple - she's an old woman whose only claim to fame is a foul mouth, a foul attitude and a wrecked husband.

And Walsh is past it too.

Gary Barlow staying would be much worse than Sharon coming back imo. He's a monumental bore.

Absolutely spot on. Not only is he a monumental bore, he put Frankie Cocozza through to the finals

It depends who she replaces. If it's Luis, it will be the best thing ever.

Agree 100%.

There's something about him that gives off a bit of a bad vibe as well, like he thinks he's above it all.

I expect that if Sharon isn't popular and Gary's "a bore" you won't be watching it any more then?

I would love sharon to come back - her and Louis would be so so funny

not true. i was struggling to remember it just last week, and i remember having a conversation about it with my friends (who did watch - more than i did! they didn't miss a week) about a month and a half back and not one of them could remember the names of any of the finalists. (the only person they remembered was rylan)

I would hate Sharon to return her pantomime acts became tiring in season 4. I think she is horrid she said awful things about Dannii. She said some nasty things about Susan Boyle. This woman is a bully and she promotes anti bullying when she is one.

She will not save the show imo.

I can't see Sharon being the new judge, Can't imagine any producer in their right mind, or even Simon Cowell for that matter, thinking Sharon's return is just what's needed to stop the viewing figures declining even more.

Not the Dannii story again :yawn::yawn::sleep:

Yeah, people need to get over the Dannii thing. Sharon and the Australian had their differences...that's all.

Osbourne wont be back if she was coming back it would have been announced by now and the adverse reaction to the thought wont help her chances