Originally Posted by Talma:
“The trouble is that Muslims are the first people to come to this country in huge numbers over a short period of time who seem to define themselves by their religion not their (adopted over time) new British nationality, and within their society there is a sizeable minority who appear to harbour strong enough dislike for the west and what we stand for to want to do us harm. This doesn't reflect on the majority but a bit more flexibility on their part to acknowledge that they now live in Britain, for whatever reason, and show a willingness to integrate fully with our traditions and culture would be welcome.”
I think you've articulated that argument very well, and it's often used, but again, I'd like to look beneath it and see how much of that is really true.
I'm not sure it's true to say that this is the first people to come in number (relative to the general population) who define themselves by their religion, and I'm not sure how many Moslems do that over and above their nationality anyway.
What is this sizeable minority who harbour a strong dislike for the West? Do you have figures? As I suggested above, my suggestion is that the media need to whip up a storm over everything these days, and I wonder how previous immigrant groups would have been reported if we'd had this media back then.
You say it doesn't reflect on the majority, and yet it clearly does as otherwise you wouldn't be saying what you say.
I also wonder what it is you'd like people to do in terms of integrating fully with our traditions and culture. Could you give some examples of what that really means? It feels like one of those phrases that is trotted out, but isn't very meaningful.
I'm not denying that there are not issues, but I am questioning the scale of it and the kind of blanket comments that go alongside them.
Originally Posted by gurney-slade:
“Examples? I don't recall Rabbis trying to impose Hasidic law, or Catholic priests campaigning for the rules of their church to apply to the general population.”
Tudor history suggests otherwise... and we've only recently had articles suggesting that moderate Jews should stand up against those suggesting women shouldn't drive, etc. One could also look at the situation in Scotland and Ireland around Catholic/Protestant issues and of course, the main point is that a lot of our law is based on christianity, whether one believes in that or not. It's all around us all the time, being 'imposed' on the general population.