Originally Posted by MartinRosen:
“Firstly, lucky none of the items grew under the Labour Government, eg Tution fees, energy prices, rail prices (just from a quick look). If everything was so 'wonderful' with the previous Government why were they voted out? Missed out something that has also increased under this Government is tax thresholds, the rate before you have to start paying income tax. It doesn't mention things that are going down, eg unemployment, inflation.
I thought NF was being fair by criticising and challenging members of all the political parties, but again it maybe what you want to hear, rather than what is actually said.
Have you actually checked how many people are homeless on the streets now compared with the time the Conservatives took office?
This wouldn't be Labour party propaganda would it?”
As Chinchin hasn't answered your questions, I hope she won't mind if I do.
All things were not wonderful under the last Labour government but up to the global financial crisis, and also since it hit, things were a lot better than it's been under the Tories.
In my view, the main reason why Labour were voted out is because they lost the public's trust regarding managing the economy. However, that was largely down to propaganda from the Conservatives and the right wing media which blamed Labour overspending for the financial rather than the bankers. When Labour came to power in 1997, they inherited a deficit of 3.9% of GDP from John Major and by 2008 (before the global financial crisis) it had fallen to 2.1%, so the right-wing propaganda about Labour overspending is not backed up by the facts.
You mentioned the Tory government increase in tax threshold which I don't think is something they should be proud of as it was largely funded by cutting benefits to some of the most vulnerable people in the country, including disabled people. The other Tory lie is that increasing tax thresholds help the poor but again the facts to do back that up. Increasing the personal allowance to £12,500 is worth only £28 a year to the poorest 20 per cent of households, but £445 a year to the richest 20 per cent. The UK’s five million lowest-paid employees gained nothing at all.
You also question whether homelessness has gone up, well, rough sleeping has increased by 55% in England, and 79% in London, since the coalition took power. That's not Labour propaganda, as you suggest, but
official government figures . The changes in housing benefits, which helped to fund tax cuts for millionaires, has been a major factor in this increase, according to homelessness charities.
I think I covered all your questions.