Stacy = robbed
XF: UK vs US vs OZ | Live Show #7 | Voting Recount
2 of 3
Originally Posted by jackel1234:
“Stacy = robbed”
“Stacy = robbed”
I do agree that everybody was on top form last night but it's down to personal opinion as to who you think performed best. The revote was not entirely down to the controversy of Christina's departure, but also due to my doubt in my own work. So don't hate the players, hate the host 
And once more, this is not the first time that has happened to me...remember when me and Union J were eliminated for 20 minutes? 
Originally Posted by jackamakka:
“
“
I do agree that everybody was on top form last night but it's down to personal opinion as to who you think performed best. The revote was not entirely down to the controversy of Christina's departure, but also due to my doubt in my own work. So don't hate the players, hate the host
”
still having stacy in then out and then the only person who agreed with the revote being the person who actually got their act eliminated before you actually did it seems a tad unfair to noonan15 when losing stacy
Originally Posted by jackel1234:
“still having stacy in then out and then the only person who agreed with the revote being the person who actually got their act eliminated before you actually did it seems a tad unfair to noonan15 when losing stacy”
“still having stacy in then out and then the only person who agreed with the revote being the person who actually got their act eliminated before you actually did it seems a tad unfair to noonan15 when losing stacy”
I just wanted a general idea. I know it may seem unfair but I feel it is more fair than having a final based on false results imo
Originally Posted by Kuda_Kunaka:
“*(*In the crowd, chanting
BRING BACK STACY!! ***”
“*(*In the crowd, chanting
BRING BACK STACY!! ***”
Take's aim from grassy knoll and fire's into the crowd
Originally Posted by jackamakka:
“
“
I just wanted a general idea. I know it may seem unfair but I feel it is more fair than having a final based on false results imo
”
but its also unfair considering you tell noonan15 he's got two acts in the final then all of a sudden he has one. Again the fact only Soppy wanted it at the start again seems unfair as Yohin and Tom both didn't want it so in majority for judges (kuda also didn't like it) it seems that nobody wanted it and that everyone was fine with it moving on except soppy who just wanted an act in the final tbh
To be honest - its Jack's show and his decisions so really if the revote stands over last night then we should honor his wishes.
Originally Posted by jackel1234:
“but its also unfair considering you tell noonan15 he's got two acts in the final then all of a sudden he has one. Again the fact only Soppy wanted it at the start again seems unfair as Yohin and Tom both didn't want it so in majority for judges (kuda also didn't like it) it seems that nobody wanted it and that everyone was fine with it moving on except soppy who just wanted an act in the final tbh”
“but its also unfair considering you tell noonan15 he's got two acts in the final then all of a sudden he has one. Again the fact only Soppy wanted it at the start again seems unfair as Yohin and Tom both didn't want it so in majority for judges (kuda also didn't like it) it seems that nobody wanted it and that everyone was fine with it moving on except soppy who just wanted an act in the final tbh”
Really jack, its a small internet game where about 5 people vote on it - a revote was done and that was Jackka's decision as host. Therefore instead of dragging this out for enternity, can we not just get on with it now?
Originally Posted by jackel1234:
“but its also unfair considering you tell noonan15 he's got two acts in the final then all of a sudden he has one. Again the fact only Soppy wanted it at the start again seems unfair as Yohin and Tom both didn't want it so in majority for judges (kuda also didn't like it) it seems that nobody wanted it and that everyone was fine with it moving on except soppy who just wanted an act in the final tbh”
“but its also unfair considering you tell noonan15 he's got two acts in the final then all of a sudden he has one. Again the fact only Soppy wanted it at the start again seems unfair as Yohin and Tom both didn't want it so in majority for judges (kuda also didn't like it) it seems that nobody wanted it and that everyone was fine with it moving on except soppy who just wanted an act in the final tbh”
I'm sorry you feel that way but unfortunately this was the plan of action I felt would be most fair considering the issues from last night continuing onto today.
If anyone has a real problem with the way proceedings were handled over the last two days feel free to contact me via PM and I'll answer anything I can within reason
EDIT: And David has a fair point. There were four votes outside the four judges votes, it's not exactly a blockbuster show of any description. I'm handling it in the manner I see fair for most people
If anyone has a real problem with the way proceedings were handled over the last two days feel free to contact me via PM and I'll answer anything I can within reason
EDIT: And David has a fair point. There were four votes outside the four judges votes, it's not exactly a blockbuster show of any description. I'm handling it in the manner I see fair for most people
Originally Posted by jackel1234:
“just saying, seems unfair 1 person who gets a place now has to go due to this shizz”
“just saying, seems unfair 1 person who gets a place now has to go due to this shizz”
I know, you've made it pretty clear over the last few posts
Originally Posted by jackel1234:
“just saying, seems unfair 1 person who gets a place now has to go due to this shizz”
“just saying, seems unfair 1 person who gets a place now has to go due to this shizz”
Yeah - we know, you've said it about five times now. No one wants the situation to be as it is; however Jack is doing what he sees to be the best cause of action.
So let's just get on with preparing for next weeks final, nstead of going round in circles...
EDIT - and why do you care so much what happens - all you do is come into the thread and make derogatory remarks about our judging, song choices and how bad everything is.
If its so bad, why do you care who makes the final?
Originally Posted by yohinnchild:
“Yeah - we know, you've said it about five times now. No one wants the situation to be as it is; however Jack is doing what he sees to be the best cause of action.
So let's just get on with preparing for next weeks final, nstead of going round in circles...
EDIT - and why do you care so much what happens - all you do is come into the thread and make derogatory remarks about our judging, song choices and how bad everything is.
If its so bad, why do you care who makes the final?”
“Yeah - we know, you've said it about five times now. No one wants the situation to be as it is; however Jack is doing what he sees to be the best cause of action.
So let's just get on with preparing for next weeks final, nstead of going round in circles...
EDIT - and why do you care so much what happens - all you do is come into the thread and make derogatory remarks about our judging, song choices and how bad everything is.
If its so bad, why do you care who makes the final?”
only certain songs because tbh your mentoring of kitty was pretty darn good until last night (the cover of florence and machine ruined it for me).
Tbh I don't care about who's through I just thinks it unfair to say one thing then something else happens. I mean bad results have happened before on shows but big whoop just go on with it and that's what should've happened instead of doing the whole revote thing.
I'm gonna leave it now as I've made my point about it and all but like I said just seems unfair to me
Lol at the drama this has turned into!! I can't stop laughing. It's like a shock elimination from the proper XF. Anyway I also think Stacy has been robbed. Fix Factor.
Originally Posted by fireemblemcraze:
“Lol at the drama this has turned into!! I can't stop laughing. It's like a shock elimination from the proper XF. Anyway I also think Stacy has been robbed. Fix Factor.”
“Lol at the drama this has turned into!! I can't stop laughing. It's like a shock elimination from the proper XF. Anyway I also think Stacy has been robbed. Fix Factor.”
Not really, seeing as the original votes cast we're skewed in the first place to ensure she got through - however no point banging on about it. The decision has been made
Dear all,
Thank you for your support for Stacy, but due to recent events she has lost her place and arguing over it is not going to bring her back. I am gutted to have lost her, already sorted my songs for her, that happened over these past two nights should not have happened and this revote should not have been needed, but it came to it, and two acts had to go.
The votes that were cast only to my act I knew nothing about until this afternoon when I seen it posted, I loved the idea of having 2 acts in the final 3 but some things are too good to be true.
I am sure now Jack has made Steve & David very happy and whilst I am gutted to have lost Stacy, I am not 100% out of the competition, Mitchell is still here so continue your support for the Overs categoryyy!!
The other judges may not have enjoyed Stacy but I personally loved being her mentor and you all seemed to love her being on the show.
Thankss! And here is too the final
Thank you for your support for Stacy, but due to recent events she has lost her place and arguing over it is not going to bring her back. I am gutted to have lost her, already sorted my songs for her, that happened over these past two nights should not have happened and this revote should not have been needed, but it came to it, and two acts had to go.
The votes that were cast only to my act I knew nothing about until this afternoon when I seen it posted, I loved the idea of having 2 acts in the final 3 but some things are too good to be true.
I am sure now Jack has made Steve & David very happy and whilst I am gutted to have lost Stacy, I am not 100% out of the competition, Mitchell is still here so continue your support for the Overs categoryyy!!
The other judges may not have enjoyed Stacy but I personally loved being her mentor and you all seemed to love her being on the show.
Thankss! And here is too the final
Originally Posted by noonan15:
“Dear all,
I am sure now Jack has made Steve & David”
“Dear all,
I am sure now Jack has made Steve & David”
Not really - its still a mess
Originally Posted by yohinnchild:
“Not really - its still a mess”
“Not really - its still a mess”
Well the problem is solved, you got your way Stacy is out the final so it is not really a mess. What else would you like Jack to do? Put on a superman cape and tie himself to the London Eye maybe?
2 of 3
