[Game] X-factor vs The Voice Live Show 3

1 of 7

pingu58011

15-04-2013

Hello and welcome to the 3rd show of X-factor vs The voice. Last week saw the elimination of Becky Hill. Later that week Steve the mentor of the girls decided to leave the panel. I searched until one person said yes. Wong_Billabong or George as we can all call him. Tonight we are at the movies. Please welcome your top 11!!

George and the Girls
Frances Wood
Amelia Lily

Kuda and the boys
Heshima Thompson
Shayne Ward
Rylan Clark
Aleks Josh

JJ and the Male Overs
Adam Issac
Danyl Johnson

Jack and the Female Overs
Bo Bruce
Toni Warne
Ruth Lorenzo

So, before we can start the show. Judges are you here?

Kuda_Kunaka

15-04-2013

I am here!

jackamakka

15-04-2013

I'm here and glad to be on the other side of the panel

justj

15-04-2013

I'm Here . On time For once

Soppyfan

15-04-2013

And I'm only here as a viewer, I hope George has better luck with the girls than I did.

pingu58011

15-04-2013

George isn`t here, but I have his comments!!

So, opening the show tonight is from the boys, and they are singing a hit from how to make it in america....It`s Aleks Josh!!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NwfHsFNJ9YI

pingu58011

15-04-2013

George`s comment

Aleks Josh
Well the song definitely suited you. I really liked the your take on the song, the style was great and the I loved the edge you gave to it.

jackamakka

15-04-2013

Aleks Josh
Aleks, this was good. It didn’t really grab me or anything and I don’t think it’s the best performance you’ve ever done. I know it’s in your style to sound effortlessness in your vocals but that was a different style of effortlessness. It almost sounded like you were bored singing. I don’t think this was the best song choice for you tonight and I think you might be in trouble.

justj

15-04-2013

Aleks Josh-I didnt really like this performance tonight .there was something missing for me tonight . I found it quite boring . Sorry but i really didnt enjoy the performance tonight

Kuda_Kunaka

15-04-2013

On the real show, I know you had a problem with nerves but in this performance, you just looked so relaxed, you sang that with so much meaning like, I wanted to throw all my dollar at you but then I remember you aren't a stripper. Lol, anyways, great performance!

pingu58011

15-04-2013

Mixed comments for Aleks tonight. If you want him through to next week, vote for him when line`s open!!

Next up is one of the ladies, and her heart will go on for us...It`s Toni Warne!!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QHe23fEHxJ8

pingu58011

15-04-2013

George`s comment

Toni
Although a very predictable song, I thought you really pulled it off. You have very strong vocals and the song really let you show them off. My only thing is I am worried that songs like this are a little dated and may affect your credibility as a modern artist

justj

15-04-2013

Toni Warne- I liked the performance but i felt the song choice was a bit predictable .Your Vocals were great but the song choice i felt was predictable

Kuda_Kunaka

15-04-2013

Now, that is a BIG song, but tonight I don't think it was right for you. It was too big for you, for me. You have a bold and strong voice and this song requires the opposite. You have to get the crucial emotion when you tackle a song like this, and with that comes smooth & soft vocals, which is kinda the opposite of what I hear from you. Good luck tonight

jackamakka

15-04-2013

Toni Warne
Toni, your vocals were back and bigger than ever tonight. I really think this song suited you well. You got a chance to show off your subtle voice as well as getting some big notes in there. It’s a very emotional song and I think you captured it well. I hope everyone else saw it like this, and hopefully I’ll see you back again next time! Vote for Toni!

pingu58011

15-04-2013

Not very good comments for Toni, as the word predictable is thrown around the board!!

Next up is one of George`s girls, and they are calling us....It`s Amelia Lily!!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HylAQFDxGLA

jackamakka

15-04-2013

Amelia Lily
Amelia, I didn’t think this was quite in your style. You definitely made it work but I’m afraid you’re regressing back into that shouty kind of performance again. I know you’ve got a new mentor so to George I would say try to look away from these kind of songs for Amelia and try to find some softer kind of songs that still complement her voice well. But good work for your first week!

puppylove7

15-04-2013

I am so sorry. I keep messing this up, either being late or not putting my all into the comments. I think it's best if I withdraw as a judge. I am so sorry.

pingu58011

15-04-2013

George`s comment

Amelia
You rocked that girl. I couldn't have asked for anything better from you. It was powerful and really showed off your skills, you rocked girl!!!

pingu58011

15-04-2013

Originally Posted by puppylove7:
“I am so sorry. I keep messing this up, either being late or not putting my all into the comments. I think it's best if I withdraw as a judge. I am so sorry.”

Awwwwww it`s ok Puppy. I`m sure other things will come up for you!!

justj

15-04-2013

I didnt think this was the best performance we have seen from you . I didnt enjoy the performance tonight

puppylove7

15-04-2013

Thanks

Kuda_Kunaka

15-04-2013

I didn't like that. The vocals I felt, were rougher than I expected. As always you did your best, but I just don't think it was right for you

pingu58011

15-04-2013

Mixed comments for Miss Lily tonight. If you want her to be safe....You know the score!!

Next is the boy who just survived the sing-off last week. Tonight we are the best he`s ever had....It`s Heshima Thompson!!!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dWwGjOCYSic

pingu58011

15-04-2013

Georges comment

Heshima
Really liked this. Your vocals really came through. It shows that you don't need a big key change to make a song powerful, you totally owned the stage and I loved it

1 of 7