They are all gorgeous, great personalities, successful and can actually sing! It could be the Cheryl Cole effect all over again! But sadly we're more likely to get stuck with Mrs O 
Simon needs to get a Saturday on the panel
1 of 2
I think a behind the scene person (such as a producer) would be a better idea... Someone who might give some professional opinions instead of empty banter (I like a bit of banter, but some real opinions would be good too).
Although I love Frankie and Rochelle because of S Club 8, they don't have a lot of personality. Neither of them have personality to be fair, they are a bit bland.
Originally Posted by COTTONHEAT:
“it would proberly be UNA as she was a judge on the ITV Sports Talent Show Lets get Gold”
“it would proberly be UNA as she was a judge on the ITV Sports Talent Show Lets get Gold”
Which is the natural stepping stone to a spot on the X Factor judging panel..
Originally Posted by PJ River:
“Although I love Frankie and Rochelle because of S Club 8, they don't have a lot of personality. Neither of them have personality to be fair, they are a bit bland.”
“Although I love Frankie and Rochelle because of S Club 8, they don't have a lot of personality. Neither of them have personality to be fair, they are a bit bland.”
I remember seeing Frankie on Never Mind The Buzzcocks once. Painful is the word that springs to mind.
If Simon was to go for one of the Saturdays, it would probably be Mollie. She's probably conventionally the prettiest/best dressed member (which is apparently all female judges are good for
) and seems to come across quite well in interviews.
Originally Posted by leonalewispr:
“Which is the natural stepping stone to a spot on the X Factor judging panel.. ”
“Which is the natural stepping stone to a spot on the X Factor judging panel..
”
it is at ITV
Originally Posted by Oliver Loxton-P:
“The only one who can sing is the ugly one. She's got absolutely no personality though.”
“The only one who can sing is the ugly one. She's got absolutely no personality though.”
Which one of the Saturdays is 'the ugly one'? Genuinely scratching my head over that. They all look pretty to me.
Yeah, if you are referring to Vanessa, and you think she is ugly? Well, none of us have a chance in the world if she's ugly! She's absolutely stunning!
Originally Posted by _elly001:
“Which one of the Saturdays is 'the ugly one'? Genuinely scratching my head over that. They all look pretty to me.”
“Which one of the Saturdays is 'the ugly one'? Genuinely scratching my head over that. They all look pretty to me.
”
Vanessa.
Originally Posted by jacqueline_gree:
“Yeah, if you are referring to Vanessa, and you think she is ugly? Well, none of us have a chance in the world if she's ugly! She's absolutely stunning!”
“Yeah, if you are referring to Vanessa, and you think she is ugly? Well, none of us have a chance in the world if she's ugly! She's absolutely stunning!”
Of course I am. The fact you automatically thought of her adds weight to the point made. She's the ugly one from The Saturdays. She can sing but she has no personality so there's no way Simon would hire her.
Originally Posted by Oliver Loxton-P:
“Vanessa.”
“Vanessa.”
Bloody hell, there's no hope for us mere mortals if someone as stunning as Vanessa could be classed as ugly.
Judging by their reality show, Mollie has the best personality, and she was rejected from X Factor..
Originally Posted by _elly001:
“I remember seeing Frankie on Never Mind The Buzzcocks once. Painful is the word that springs to mind.
If Simon was to go for one of the Saturdays, it would probably be Mollie. She's probably conventionally the prettiest/best dressed member (which is apparently all female judges are good for) and seems to come across quite well in interviews.”
“I remember seeing Frankie on Never Mind The Buzzcocks once. Painful is the word that springs to mind.
If Simon was to go for one of the Saturdays, it would probably be Mollie. She's probably conventionally the prettiest/best dressed member (which is apparently all female judges are good for
) and seems to come across quite well in interviews.”
Agree with you and we seem to watch the same shows. On the other hand, she has the hotness going for her.
Originally Posted by _elly001:
“If Simon was to go for one of the Saturdays, it would probably be Mollie. She's probably conventionally the prettiest/best dressed member (which is apparently all female judges are good for) and seems to come across quite well in interviews.”
“If Simon was to go for one of the Saturdays, it would probably be Mollie. She's probably conventionally the prettiest/best dressed member (which is apparently all female judges are good for
) and seems to come across quite well in interviews.”
She also has a very annoying lisp.
If it came down to one of the Saturday's I think we all know it would be Frankie who would get the job.
I think Rochelle or Mollie have the personality for it...but I couldn't imagine them having a huge input on the judging panel.
Originally Posted by dillan:
“Judging by their reality show, Mollie has the best personality”
“Judging by their reality show, Mollie has the best personality”
Completely agree. I thought she was fabulous on their reality TV show!
To be honest, I think Rochelle would be the only one who would have the right personality for the judging panel. And she's obviously otherwise engaged for this series.
One thing that could be interesting is if they had Rochelle and her husband Marvin from JLS on the panel. Would be television gold to see them compete against one another and having typical couples arguments.
One thing that could be interesting is if they had Rochelle and her husband Marvin from JLS on the panel. Would be television gold to see them compete against one another and having typical couples arguments.
Originally Posted by Stuart1000:
“To be honest, I think Rochelle would be the only one who would have the right personality for the judging panel. And she's obviously otherwise engaged for this series.
One thing that could be interesting is if they had Rochelle and her husband Marvin from JLS on the panel. Would be television gold to see them compete against one another and having typical couples arguments.”
“To be honest, I think Rochelle would be the only one who would have the right personality for the judging panel. And she's obviously otherwise engaged for this series.
One thing that could be interesting is if they had Rochelle and her husband Marvin from JLS on the panel. Would be television gold to see them compete against one another and having typical couples arguments.”
Marvin-Rochelle-Tulisa-Simon or
Marvin - Rochelle-Nicole-Gary
1 of 2
