It's been done before...I can't find the old thread and we need light-hearted threads.

So due to S7 developments and 50th announcements which companion do you associate with each Doctor?
Doctor 8/ Grace Holloway is straightforward I suppose.

Cheers

Okay:
Hartnell - Ian & Barbara (sorry, can't have one without the other)
Troughton - Jamie
Pertwee - Jo Grant (but I love him with Liz Shaw)
Baker - Adric (nah, only joking - gotta be the one and only Sarah Jane)
Davison - Tegan
C Baker - Peri
McCoy - D'uh!
Chris E - Billie
Tenant - Donna
Smith - River (controversial, moi?)

I was thinking about this thread earlier today!
Couldn't complete the last one as I was a classic who noob, but now I can!

Hartnell/Susan
Troughton/Jamie
Pertwee/Liz
T.Baker/Sarah
Davison/Tegan
C.Baker/Peri
McCoy/Ace
McGann/Grace
Eccleston/Rose
Tennant/Donna
Smith/Amy

Snap.Good choices. I associate Donna with 10 and Rose with 9

Hartnell - Susan
Troughton - Jamie
Pertwee - Sarah Jane
Baker - Leela
Davison - Tegan
C Baker - Peri
McCoy - Ace
Ecclestone - Rose
Tenant - Donna
Smith - Amy

Hartnell - Susan
Troughton - Jamie
Pertwee - Jo
T Baker - Sarah Jane
Davison - Nyssa
C Baker - Peri
McCoy - Ace
McGann - Grace
Eccleston - Rose
Tennant - Rose
Smith - Amy

Thank you! I was worried about posting it as it's the first time I've actually posted some sort of opinion on Classic Who!

You did yourself proud. They were all correct, except the 1st Doctor (definitely Ian Chesterton)


That said, my personal subjective favourite list is a little different:

1st: Chatterton ( I love vicki too though; possibly the most underrated companion)

2nd: Jamie and Victoria (such a sweet pair and a cool little gang with the Doctor)

3rd: Liz Shaw (shame she had to leave. I don't agree with Lett's / Dicks reasons for getting rid of her (she was too intelligent)

4th: Both Romanas (I like them both in different ways). Actually Sarah-Jane is my least favourite 4th Doc companion.

5th: Do I have to choose someone? Okay, Peri, because I didn't utterly despise every second she was onscreen, which was a step up from the others

6th: Peri again. Not particularly great but we know who the competition is :P

7th: obviously Ace, although she couldn't act.

8th: yeah, that woman, I guess.

9th: sigh..

10th: Can I choose Granddad?

11th: Amy Pond, for her first season

10 & Wilf is interesting. Wilf ultimately led to his end.

I couldn't get it down to one companion for some Doctors.

Hartnell - Ian and Barbara

Troughton - Jamie and Zoe

Pertwee - Sarah Jane

T Baker - Romana II

Davison - Nyssa, Tegan and Turlough

C Baker - Peri

McCoy - Ace (TV) and Bernice Summerfield (novels)

McGann - Grace (TV), Lucie (audios) and Fitz (novels)

Eccleston - Rose

Tennant - Donna and Wilf

Smith - River Song, Amy and Rory

First - Ian and Barbara equally
Second - Jamie
Third - Jo
Fourth - Sarah Jane
Fifth - Tegan
Sixth - Peri
Seventh - Ace
Eighth - Grace
Ninth - Rose
Tenth - Martha
Eleventh - Amy

Based on who I think of straight away with each respective Doctor:


Hartnell - Susan, Ian and Barbara
Troughton - Jamie and Zoe
Pertwee - The Brigadier
T. Baker - Sarah Jane
Davison - Tegan, Adric and Nyssa
C. Baker - Peri
McCoy - Ace
McGann - Grace
Eccleston - Rose
Tennant - Rose
Smith - It should be Amy, but when I think 11, I think River.

Some nice contributions. Are people deliberately disassociating Rose and Ten?

Hartnell - Barbara

Troughton - Jamie

Pertwee - Jo Grant

Tom Baker - Sarah Jane Smith

Davison - Nyssa

Colin Baker - Peri

McCoy - Ace
McGann - Grace


Eccleston - Rose

Tennant - Martha

Smith - Amy Pond

Having only NuWho:

9th - Rose
10th - Rose/Donna
11th - Amy/Rory

Hartnell - Barbara

Troughton - Jamie

Pertwee - Jo Grant

Tom Baker - Leela

Davison - Tegan

Colin Baker - Peri

McCoy - Ace

McGann - Grace

Eccleston - Rose

Tennant - Donna

Smith - River

I'm surprised at the number of people pairing 10 with Donna over Rose. I felt sure it would be the other way round. Having said that, I'm in total agreement!

NuWho

Eccleston - the combination of Jack and Rose in the end of his season
Tennant - Donna, for me Ten was at his best when he was with Donna and most of my favorite stories from his era are with Donna as well
Smith - the whole wibbly wobbly timey wimey Pond family, who were like a surrogate family for the Doctor

First - Susan
Second - Jamie
Third - Jo
Fourth - Sarah Jane
Fifth - Tegan
Sixth - Peri
Seventh - Ace
Eighth - Grace
Nineth - Rose
Tenth - Rose
Eleventh - Amy and Rory

Hartnell - Susan
Troughton - Jamie
Pertwee - Jo
Baker - SJS
Davison - Nyssa
Baker - Peri
McCoy - Ace
McGann - erm, Grace
Ecclston - Rose
Tennant - Donna
Eleven - Amy

Hartnell - Susan
Troughton - Jamie
Pertwee - Jo
Baker - Sarah Jane
Davison - Tegan
Baker - Peri
McCoy - Ace
McGann - Grace
Ecclston - Rose
Tennant - Donna
Eleven - Amy

Glad to see some appreciation for Vicki. I loved her work with Ian and Barbara. Some find her annoying, but I only thought she was annoying in The Web Planet, and who watches that anyway?

1. Ian and Babs
2.Jamie
3.Jo Grant
4. Sarah-Jane
5. Tegan
6. Peri
7. Ace
8. Gracw
9. Rose
10. Donna and Wilf
11. River Song

[LIST][*]Hartnell - Susan, Ian and Barbara[*]Troughton - Jamie[*]Pertwee - Jo Grant[*]T. Baker - Sarah Jane[*]Davison - Tegan (she was in all of his stories, apart from two)[*]C. Baker - Peri[*]McCoy - Ace[*]McGann - Grace[*]Eccleston - Rose[*]Tennant - Tricky, but I think Donna[*]Smith - Amy (so far)[/LIST]

I may be influenced by the Big Finish stuff as some companions have been doing audios with their Doctors more than others:

Hartnell - Ian (also Barbara and Susan)
Troughton - Jamie or Zoe
Pertwee - Sarah Jane (also Jo)
T. Baker - Leela (also K9 and Romana)
Davison - Nyssa (also Tegan and Turlough)
C. Baker - Peri (also Mel - she's been in a bunch of audios lately!)
McCoy - Ace
McGann - Grace
Eccleston - Rose
Tennant - Rose (also Martha and Donna)
Smith - Clara (who's this Amy person )