In a one off charity special ...

Obviously never going to happen, but anyone else think this would be awesome?!

I can dream!

Yeah, that would be pretty awesome

Only if it was the RDJ version, cannot stand weasel faced Cumberbund

How about the Tom Baker version?

Sorry make your own thread, Cumberbund is awesome.

Why would I make my own thread? the title says 'The Doctor meets Sherlock' and that is what I am talking about

I wouldnt have minded him meeting the Basil Rathbone version either, and yes Tom Baker would be great!

Grrrr damn you!

I thought you might say that.

For children in need?

should be a laugh

If you can't wait for it to happen (and it probably won't) there are some brilliant fan-made vids on youtube which create just this scenario.

If you search "Wholock" they will come up, but off the top of my head I can recommend "A Study in Time". Then some of the others will appear in the realted vids sidebar. Enjoy

Ta, will give them a watch!

No worries
Let me know what you think!

That mockney crap isn`t sherlock by a long shot. Not even fit to lick Jeremy Bretts boots

Will do, I will watch them tomorrow night!

Look out for my update...

Getting a bit OT here... but I quite enjoy RDJ, even though Jeremy Brett is, quite clearly, *THE* Sherlock Holmes.
Benedict Cumberbatch's Sherlock is a different take again, but there's nothing wrong in that. When they made the Basil Rathbone films they had Holmes versus the Nazis at least once, so there's nothing wrong with the character being re-imagined. Amd Martin Freeman is just a brilliant Dr Watson.

Banks - I'll be here

I've never watched Sherlock so I can't comment but I would love a Red Dwarf crossover for CIN or RND (not quite on-topic, I know).

Bumpity-bump!

Saw this else where.. apologies if it's a repost!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q3bGYljQ5Uw

You mean like Sherlock

In the Doctor Who Universe Sherlock is a fictional character. It would only work if they met in the Land of Fiction or something which would rather detract from Sherlock's input!

I've heard that excuse used before, that Sherlock is already a fictional character in the Whoniverse, therefore a Doctor Who/Sherlock crossover would never happen - however, that's not quite true if you think about it.
The Sherlock of old IS a fictional character - but it could be argued the Sherlock played by Benedict Cumberbatch is not really that Sherlock. It would be quite easy for a few quick throw away remarks from the Doctor about the coincidence of his name, his job and Watson (with Sherlock replying "I know, I know...you couldn't make it up, huh?") and then on with the plot. It's unlikely but this is Doctor Who and anything is possible.

If old Sherlock Holmes is real in the 1800's, they would did to do a biopic based on the true story of Joseph Wiseman aka The Real-Life Sherlock Holmes.

Actually the Sherlock and Who universes have intersected a bit with Big Finish. Jago and Litefoot (originally from Talons of Weng Chiang and now with their own spin-off series) recently met Arthur Conan Doyle and ended up impersonating Holmes and Watson for an investigation. A rather interesting spin on the Hound of the Baskervilles then developed

I'm glad that got mentioned here, it is very brilliantly done.
I forgive them the continuity error with Watson's jacket at the end!

Rather have a who/star trek crossover. Have the borg fight with the daleks and the tardis lands on the enterprise.