Just for fun!

Both. And don't bother bringing Sharon back (as much as I'd like to see her return).

Out of those 2, Nicole.

Nicole by far. I love Mel but not if it means getting rid of Nicole. She's the only humorous person on the show left.

Now if you made a poll between Nicole and Louis or Mel B and Louis. Mel B and Nicole would both win by a landfall.

I would rather have Nicole and Mel B on the same panel. They'd be like chalk and cheese it would be funny

I don't like the idea of Mel B and Sharon being on the same panel. You need a gentle judge e.g. Nicole. I think the panel would be too harsh having both Mel and Sharon.

I love the both of them. I actually think they would work together better than Nicole & Sharon. I am just against Sharon returning! Nicole and Mel would be perfect because Nicole can be the sugar-coating funny and bubbly one while Mel can be the B*tc*

Nicole by a longgggggg shot. People found Mel B "entertaining and honest' - I found her rude and ignorant plus she has such little talent (if any) therefore she has no right to be a Grade A b*tch.

Nicole is talented, beautiful, funny, a great mentor and totally stole the show last year. Team Nicole!

Nicole definitely.

I went off Nicole last year a bit, I didn't like her acts, she was acting too OTT I prefered her when she was a bit more laid back.

Mel B is a much better judge.

Nicole.

i`d like both tbh as much as i love Sharon i think a Mel & Nicole could work Mel being the loud "outrageous" one Nicole being the softer one

a Sharon / Mel B would be a too much as much as i love both

Nicole. I can't think of a worse judge than Mel B.

Nicole, but I would love Nicole, Mel B and Sharon on the same panel. Get rid of Tulisa, Louis and even Gary.

I'd like them both to be on it I like Sharon she's a good judge but a bad mentor plus she's been on it before and I want to see someone new. But if I had to pick between Nicole and Mel I would pick Nicole.

nicole

I like both, but I voted for Nicole.

I think Mel B ccould make for some entertaining viewing but I love Nicole and her personality so I voted for her.

I voted for Mel B but in all honesty either of them is fine by me so long as they're getting rid of Tulisa regardless.

Was in the audience and saw both of them last year (Mel in Manchester, Nicole in Newcastle on her first day) and Nicole is a far superior judge. Mel is just nasty to the contestants for no reason in particular, and then gets annoyed when the audience boos her.

I'd rather Mel B instead of Sharon. But since Sharon is confirmed Nicole is best alongside her.
I can just imagine the rows between Mel B and Sharon already if they were on the same panel.

neither