Originally Posted by ItsRyanYall:
“Paulina RWHObio?”
“Paulina RWHObio?”
she is a latin superstar and currently a judge on the voice of spain
Results:Who should get the final 2 sports on X Factor USA ?
Kelly Rowland
55 (68.75%)
Hilary Duff
13 (16.25%)
Jennifer Love Hewitt
6 (7.50%)
Paulina Rubio
6 (7.50%)
Faith Hill
9 (11.25%)
Cheryl Cole
44 (55.00%)
Voters: 80. You can't vote on this poll right now - are you signed in?
X Factor USA Judges:- Battle of the Girls - Who should get the job?
2 of 3
Originally Posted by gemhud:
“hilary duff posted X on her twitter about 1 hour ago looks like she's doing it.”
“hilary duff posted X on her twitter about 1 hour ago looks like she's doing it.”
yea I just saw that US blogs are going crazy over it hahaha. Would be a massive gig for her
Originally Posted by gemhud:
“hilary duff posted X on her twitter about 1 hour ago looks like she's doing it.”
“hilary duff posted X on her twitter about 1 hour ago looks like she's doing it.”
This a joke?
Originally Posted by Mikedoc90:
“This a joke?”
“This a joke?”
No Joke! Im glad Simon is thinking outside the box, as he did with signing Dannii and Cheryl at the beginning, he is looking for mentors.
https://twitter.com/HilaryDuff/statu...58842711818240
Originally Posted by Helen_Smith3:
“Hilary Duff is such a random choice, she hasn't even done anything for over 5 years that I know of.”
“Hilary Duff is such a random choice, she hasn't even done anything for over 5 years that I know of.”
remember when dannii came onto our panel everyone said the same. Simon is quite good at knowing who will work, and she was like the american sweetheart, she done so much more than disney though.
Originally Posted by gemhud:
“hilary duff posted X on her twitter about 1 hour ago looks like she's doing it.”
“hilary duff posted X on her twitter about 1 hour ago looks like she's doing it.”
As much as i love Hilary i don`t wanna get my hopes up :/
the only thing that say`s no to me is that Demi is also there 2 young Disney stars? idk imo i would`ve got rid of Demi and replaced her with Hilary to begin with
There is this article from Feb about Hilary being in London, and having a meeting, and at the bottom it speculates an XF role, also saying she signed a Fox deal last year for this coming fall
http://ohnotheydidnt.livejournal.com/75643674.html
Was Hilary even that sucessful in music ? I know she has done well in acting but I didn't think she done that well with her music it just seems like a random choice if she becomes a judge.
Originally Posted by Barry_Clarke:
“remember when dannii came onto our panel everyone said the same. Simon is quite good at knowing who will work, and she was like the american sweetheart, she done so much more than disney though.”
“remember when dannii came onto our panel everyone said the same. Simon is quite good at knowing who will work, and she was like the american sweetheart, she done so much more than disney though.”
He has been very good at knowing what will work in the UK, but he has no idea what will work in the US.
Originally Posted by justj:
“I dont think a panel of Kelly-Hilary-Demi-Simon would work”
“I dont think a panel of Kelly-Hilary-Demi-Simon would work”
only time will tell justj
Originally Posted by InMyArms:
“How is Kelly leading this? She was awful on our version.”
“How is Kelly leading this? She was awful on our version.”
mate do u ever have anything good 2 say all u seem 2 do is moan haha no offense!
Originally Posted by InMyArms:
“How is Kelly leading this? She was awful on our version.”
“How is Kelly leading this? She was awful on our version.”
It is quite funny how the two judges who seem to be hated the most on here are leading this poll, I like them both though so I'm glad to see it.
From the people on this list, Kelly and Cheryl. I wasn't a massive fan of Kelly on the UK version but I think she'll be much more at home on the US version and she does know her stuff. I like Cheryl and it would be good exposure for her in the US.
If Hilary is a judge it will be interesting to see how the panel works. Her and Demi seem to have similar personalities so it could either work well or end up being dull. I like Hilary though and I've read that she is planning on restarting her music career so this does make sense. Being on the show would get her some much needed publicity.
If Hilary is a judge it will be interesting to see how the panel works. Her and Demi seem to have similar personalities so it could either work well or end up being dull. I like Hilary though and I've read that she is planning on restarting her music career so this does make sense. Being on the show would get her some much needed publicity.
Originally Posted by Barry_Clarke:
“mate do u ever have anything good 2 say all u seem 2 do is moan haha no offense!”
“mate do u ever have anything good 2 say all u seem 2 do is moan haha no offense!”
I don't think I moan as much as you go around saying things are confirmed when they are actually not.
I like Hilary Duff.. but I think Demi and Hilary together is like having two of the same?
Both of them on the panel wouldn't really show diversity.
Simon, Demi, Kelly, Ne-Yo would be a pretty decent panel.
Cheryl Cole belongs on X-factor UK. She's not relevant in the US so there would be no point her doing it there.
Both of them on the panel wouldn't really show diversity.
Simon, Demi, Kelly, Ne-Yo would be a pretty decent panel.
Cheryl Cole belongs on X-factor UK. She's not relevant in the US so there would be no point her doing it there.
Originally Posted by Barry_Clarke:
“Therefore X Factor is apparently looking for judges who are good mentors, have experience in the business and are committed to working on the show, giving both good comments and have personality on the camera.”
“Therefore X Factor is apparently looking for judges who are good mentors, have experience in the business and are committed to working on the show, giving both good comments and have personality on the camera.”
Tweedy isn't any of the above and Fox would never take another risk with a talentless unknown X factor reject who was rumoured to be suing them. She's not on their final list.
2 of 3
