Not just that, but fans think she made promises not to go back. Which she hasn't! Is it just me or does money talk?

Not a surprise, Fox wants judges that are talented, attractive popular in America and are excited to join the show, Tweedy is none of those.

Yes but the majority wouldn't mind as long as she's on their television screens again. I doubt she would have been offered the job anyway, her name was thrown in the mix to stir up some publicity

im shocked about cheryl cole. maybe she is gunna do idol

She actually has. She said on Twitter more than once that X Factor is in her past and she doesn't want to go back.

It does make me laugh that people still believe the BS that Cheryl is even being considered to go back. Why would she? She's not known in the US. The ratings fell last season from the first. If Mariah Carey cannot prevent American Idol from going down in the Ratings what hope would Cheryl have to raise X Factor ratings? None.

LOL! The finale of Idol was 50% down in ratings this year with Mariah Carey on the panel. You seriously think they'd consider Cheryl Cole who isn't known in America to come and rescue Idol?

I think it will be Simon, Demi, Paulina, and Kelly. and I'm happy with that

Simon posted some tweets about missing the Idol panel with Randy and Paula. Is this an indication that a Simon, Demi, Randy, and Paula panel could actually happen now?

I think it would be odd putting the Idol panel on XF.

I would love to see simon, demi and paula...

but I don't think is gonna happen