It's ridiculous now! It's like she's doing it on purpose! She always has to be the loudest, always vowing for attention!

Everyone she opens her mouth I feel like muting! I didn't use to mind her but ever since Alesha joined the panel, it seems she is always trying to out do her and it's just do working!

BGT is the only successful programme that Amanda has anything to do with and she's been desperate to remain on it for years.

I like Amanda- I don't know why most people on here dislike her. Maybe it's as soon as one person says they don't the others think they have to copy

Nope, I'm not copying anyone...just stating my honest opinion.

I really like Amanda too lovely genuine person

I don't like her because she has a very nasty side. She was horrible about a magic act in Series 2, she said that she wanted Ronan Parke to win minutes after Jai McDowall had won and she pretended to yawn at the laser harp guy last year when he said that he had constructed the whole equipment himself.

Yep that was totally bitchy of her and I can't stand her.

Or maybe people just don't like her.

Exactly i remember all that, she has a nice "image" but her mask has well and truly fallen off many times on the live shows when the editors cant edit it all out. How she is a judge on a talent show is one of life's mysteries to me...

She's harmless enough , she just likes the attention and she's not alone in that . With those legs I forgive anything !

She talks shit doesn't she?

Its David bloody Walliams I want to mute

She doesn't really annoy me as such, I can put up with her.

But there are times when she is transparently false and saying something purely to jump on a band wagon. And she has one hell of an ego that rears its head at times.

God she is VILE, when will she be sacked?

Aye, about as genuine as Katie Price.

All a load of rent-a-quote tabloid, attention seeking, harlets.

My mum is in her 70's, and when the Magician put the ring on her finger and Amanda said 'You know I'm married', my mum just said out of the blue, 'It's never stopped you before love'.

Made me chuckle.

She is worse when you actually go see the auditions. Back in 2011 she made this guy stop singing a song dedicated to his dead friend, and demanded he sang a cover of something cheerful. Just all round nasty person.

Bit strong, isn't it? So how would you describe a mass murderer??

She's an attractive woman who has opinions that not everyone agrees with (and is nowhere near as bitchy as Simon). The dislike for her is way OTT. I don't always agree with her myself; I disagreed over Jai MacDowell vs Ronan Parkes, but she's entitled to her opinion.

People will deny it's jealousy, saying "what's to be jealous of", and I would say "plenty". I like her and think, on the whole, she's a fair judge.

To answer the opening post - no. It's these constant Amanda-bashing threads that are annoying. Why can't you think of something positive to say instead?