• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • TV Shows: Reality
  • Britain's Got Talent
Am I the only one that thinks that...
Robertfitz
27-05-2013
....the little girl singer isn't even all that good? Don't get me wrong, she is definately talented but the judges (and some people on here actually) are going on like she's the next coming of Jesus or something.

There's been far better child singers throughout the years on BGT and she isn't up there with the best of them. Imo

We all know what will happen. She'll place top 3, won't win, then go on to release a cover album a couple of months later that will un-doubtfully flop.
Lord Kram
27-05-2013
Completely 100% agree
boysforpele
27-05-2013
Disagree. She is 11! She shows very good power and control. Her diction and pronunciation needs developing and sometimes affects pitch. But she is also captivating. Very good - better than many acts on X Factor.
ursula321
27-05-2013
I just don't like child acts full stop! Yes she could sing, but if she is that good she will still be able to sing at 18 with more experience and something to sing about.
Cosya
27-05-2013
She has her final act all ready.

She will stand and sing while the bloke with the broom will do a dramatic dance around her
Donna65
27-05-2013
Thought she was pretty amazing to be honest, to pull off a song as difficult as that one, even though it wasn't entirely appropriate for an 11 year old to sing.
Vodka_Drinka
27-05-2013
Agree. She should come back when she's 16.
TinyMikey
27-05-2013
It's the law. You must incessantly praise all children on a talent show, you must tell them that they're your favourite ever act, you must vote for them regardless of merit. Honesty is not allowed.

Obviously Simon and whoever else shouldn't just say "you're crap", but the way the judges ramble on like EVERY SINGLE CHILD they see is the next biggest thing really annoys me. It's almost like constructive criticism isn't allowed and the whole thing just sets them up for an even bigger fall when they do eventually get told that they're really not all that.

The dance troupe tonight were AWFUL to the point of being un-watchable, all they did was make a lot of noise whilst jumping around (out of sync). I realise they're a lot older and had a hell of a lot more time to perfect their act, but go back and watch Diversity's performances a few years ago and it just doesn't even compare.

Arisxandra was good but nothing AMAZING. I agree with the above posts, she should come back when she's older.
flowers786
27-05-2013
Originally Posted by Cosya:
“She has her final act all ready.

She will stand and sing while the bloke with the broom will do a dramatic dance around her”

i loled at this
moose82
27-05-2013
yes she is good but this performance was not amazing she shouted the high notes it was totally the wrong song for her to sing, i dont care if your 11 years old or an old professional shouting is not singing, but she will have a career in the future, i just think shes not as good as everyone is raving about her.
Astonvils
27-05-2013
Originally Posted by moose82:
“yes she is good but this performance was not amazing she shouted the high notes it was totally the wrong song for her to sing, i dont care if your 11 years old or an old professional shouting is not singing, but she will have a career in the future, i just think shes not as good as everyone is raving about her.”

I agree too.
lightblues
27-05-2013
I disagree ,she has an adult voice in a child's body,quite amazing , if you think she's not that good you're just jealous and can't recognise gene talent regardless of age
Pink Knight
27-05-2013
For her age she is good. Trying to keep her voice deep sends it all over the place though.
Vol
27-05-2013
Her shtick is basically just that she sounds a lot older than she is when singing. If a 20 year old contestant gave the same vocal performance then everyone would be (correctly) saying that she was very pitchy and especially woeful at the lower beginning part of the song.

It was a pretty poor field tonight. Even though I personally found Aaron vastly more entertaining, I was not surprised she got through.
Robertfitz
27-05-2013
Originally Posted by lightblues:
“I disagree ,she has an adult voice in a child's body,quite amazing , if you think she's not that good you're just jealous and can't recognise gene talent regardless of age”

Damn. You caught me out. I'm just soo jealous
BlueStreak
28-05-2013
Originally Posted by lightblues:
“I disagree ,she has an adult voice in a child's body,quite amazing , if you think she's not that good you're just jealous and can't recognise gene talent regardless of age”

So basically, if a negative opinion is given of an act, it's pure jealousy and not the fact that someone simply doesn't think the act is as good, in their opinion, as another?

twingle
28-05-2013
Originally Posted by lightblues:
“I disagree ,she has an adult voice in a child's body,quite amazing , if you think she's not that good you're just jealous and can't recognise gene talent regardless of age”

Ah but to me that isn't a talent but a gift! Gabz the 14yr old sang a song she wrote herself now that to me is talent
lovecat86
28-05-2013
I do not like people of any age, sex, race, etc... coming on singing cover versions! In a few years she could go on XF. If she had original material, fair enough.
lovecat86
28-05-2013
Originally Posted by twingle:
“Ah but to me that isn't a talent but a gift! Gabz the 14yr old sang a song she wrote herself now that to me is talent”

Seconded.
tawny
28-05-2013
She is only good because she is a kid. Kids shouldn't on the show. Hope she doesn't win
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map