You can say the sun looks green, or that a ferrari sounds like a hair dryer that doesn't make it true. It just means you have bad judgement on that particular subject.

I fail to see what comparison you're attempting to make.

Whether they were good or bad is not a fact, it's all a matter of personal opinion and taste. It's not a fact they were great, it's not a fact they were crap.

I thought they were decent, but given most of the other acts tonight, that means a lot.

They were one of the best acts tonight

I agree , might not be everybody taste , but can't deny they are talented musicians .

to say they where crap is harsh

I did not like them , I wonder if they have heard the Nina Simone,s version of the song just beautiful,...

luminshites - dreadful - out of tune - pitchy - dull - dreary and full of themselves

But those things are facts, not opinions. There is no such thing as a right or wrong opinion....

I thought they were brilliant

they were completely forgettable and the fat chick was WAY better

I liked them, they should sing that 70s tune uptown top Rankin....

You should listen to the Bee Gees version (they wrote it), anyone who things luminshites version is better needs a lobotomy - flat emotionless drivel compared to emotional tender and touching

Thought they were brilliant best act tonight by miles

I thought that they were much better in their previous audition. I really thought they were good then.
But tonight I thought that they were competent enough, but just too bland for my liking.

They're very talented, but I felt like tonight they just didn't impress me like they did before. They just seemed generic and bland compared to the last time that they were on.

So good that nobody on Twitter were talking about them.

I thought they were good, I liked them

They were okay but preferred Rosie.

I wasn't at all impressed with them either - distinctly average IMO.

Actually, not blown away by anyone on tonight's programme.

Agree. Simon sees pound signs but I didn't think they were that great. Best of a poor batch tonight though.

Attention seeking thread.
Are you too important to just put 'Luminites were crap' in the pinned discussion?

Twitter isn't the be all and end all of judging how much someone is liked - the Luminites got through on public vote tonight which costs money, so I would say that mattered more, no?

I didn't rate them either. A good song ruined. I wouldn't even have had them in the top three.

Even I'm not a fan, but I did think they delivered a great performance tonight and deserve a place in the final.

they won simply because everyone else was pretty dire in comparison to the standard of the last 2 semis