Walliams camp and annoying. Might as well have that pineapple dance studios pillock louis in there and be done with it.

Amanda brings nothing to the show. Famous for being married to Les Dennis and that's it. The first couple of seasons we saw plenty of tears from her and we soon got tired of that.

Please Mr Cowell replace both of these non entities for the next season. Walliams is a good comedian but this is not the right platform for him

He won't replace them. Unless i am mistaken didn't he actually say live on air last night that it was the best panel he had ever worked with and they would all be back next year. This prompted Amanda to immediately hug him... probably saying Thank God to herself !!!

Simon always says that. Same on xf.

Looks like itv are moving bgt so that means Simon wont be able to do it since hes on the us xf.

And if Simons not there then Amanda and David wont be there.

Where does it say they're moving BGT?

I can't imagine they will because if they move it so that it clashes with his US X Factor work, it will invariably mean it'll clash with the UK X Factor as well so that won't happen.

http://forums.digitalspy.co.uk/showthread.php?t=1834705

I think theyre swapping places. XF will be moved to spring, bgt to autumn.

The strange thing is that itv has commisioned a new dance show this year starting late aug. Will be on for 6 weeks.
That means xf will air october which is really odd.

Interesting. I can't see Cowell being happy with that idea - unless he's decided he wants to do both X Factor's and sacrifice BGT.

Moving X Factor UK would allow him to do both I suppose.

Maybe thats why hes been mentioning Louis Walsh often.
He could easily put Louis on bgt and himself on xf if Itv wants the programs to switch places.

But if itv will air xf in oct it will run until xmas and then the live shows come jan 14.

So he could join in then as a fifth judge.

I find Amanda Holden so desperate. She is nowhere near talented or informed enough to be judging anything. Got by on her looks and they are failing fast.

Beg to differ on Walliams , I think it's the perfect platform for him.

I would replace the two women , their comments are basically irrelevant . So , two new , good looking women who don't get on would be perfect

She is talented as an stage actress, her nomination for a Lawrence Olivier award show's that.

Walliams to stay, because I enjoy everything about him........Holden to go, because I enjoy nothing about her

People keep saying this. She's been in West End productions.

What has Cowell ever done?

He thinks he can judge talent but he's never performed in his life

There's no point ripping apart a panel which works. While the sum of it's parts may not be popular together they make the show easier to watch.

I know people keep saying what has Amanda ever done but she has been in the buisness for years. She's been in stage musicals and won/been nominated for awards. She has also been in several dramas over the years, including cutting it which popular at the time. She isn't really just famous for Les Dennis and Neil Morrisey as much as some people would like to think.

Get rid of Williams , keep the fried eggs , she's good entertainment

I love David and find him so funny! In fact I love all 4 of them together.

Does Amanda actually have a job outside BGT?

Or is she like Sinitta, whose entire career completely depends on Simon Cowell putting her on TV?

Yes please

The question is though, who would you replace them with?

Oh she was in the great sitcom Big Top wasn't she?

She certainly has a good portfolio of acting jobs in the past, I think her last series being Wild at Heart and then of course she was Fiona in Shrek until Kimberly Walsh took over.

She did host the search for Jesus Christ Superstar.... but in a hosting role I thought she was poor. She will be hoping that BGT goes on for a long time yet and that she remains the "Louis" of the panel.

So much for your humble opinion. Mr Cowell having asked both to return next year, proving he's the better Judge of who is on the panel..: As for being famous for being wed to a one trick pony?? your having a laugh

I actually like Amanda And David sometimes.

Not keen on Alesha though. I find her a little... hmm... not racist, per se, but just... whenever a non-white act performs, she always has to mention that they have 'soul' or 'flavour'. Does my head in.

Aww no please, I love David

Has Sinitta ever been on any of Cowell's panels . He seems to like her very much . I see both of them in the limo together after the show.

Maybe Sinitta could do Amand's job .

Replace them all this year, my ideal panel starting from the left
Russell Brand
Judi Dench
Emma Watson
Lenny Henry