Originally Posted by kp2ni:
“I agree that if he was always given bad contestants he probably wouldn't be on the show but I think that is the same with most established pros on shows like this.
Julianne always got good contestants but decided to walk away. Flavia & Vincent were bound to get duds this year & decided that it was better to leave on a high, Maksim standard of contestants was getting worst so he left. Erin wasn't getting partners that could win so walked and lets not bring up Aliona.
It is the producers who decides the pairings not Derek. I just don't see Derek walking in to a producer's office and demanding a good partner or threading to quit. It is up to the producers. All the pros want the best celeb they can get it is only natural as it gives them a better chance to win and to show off their choreography & ability as a dancer and teacher.”
I do watch DWTS but I haven't watched it consistently through every series.
I believe that Julianne got a few celebs that weren't that great. After she'd won twice she probably felt there was nothing more to prove and didn't Julianne eventually walk away because she wanted to pursue a career in music and acting which she has done very successfully?
I think someone like Derek might have an agent who does the negotiations for him - I don't have proof of that mind

I agree any pro in his position would do the same & he is no doubt good for ratings but what more has he got left to prove? I'm sure he can't be short of offers in the world of entertainment?
Although I'm very sad that Flavia and Vincent have left, I'm happy they left on a high & I agree they most likely would have got duds if they'd come back but they would have accepted the task graciously as they've had them before - as did Erin whomever she was given. It's a pity Erin and Vincent never won but I think they can be more than satisfied with what they achieved on the show. Probably they all felt they had nothing more to prove on SCD and as they all said in their statements they were leaving to pursue other projects.
It's just with some pros and I'm not just talking about Derek on DWTS - on our series as well, you get the feeling they think they should have preferrential treatment, and then if that happens like it has done in the past on both shows all you're left with is a one sided showcase for a particular pro's work dominating the show.