Originally Posted by priscilla:
“Oh I can see this happening, she was already drooling over him when she first saw him. Kat/Alfie will never have a non cheating relationship, Kat 'I'm a dirty girl' Moon is unable to not cheat and Alfie 'doormat/mug' Moon can't help but forgive her :yawn:
I really wish TPTB would stop trying to make out Kat/Alfie are meant to be together or that they are a great love story, more like a crap story.”
Thing is, when Kat and Alfie first got together, they were supposed to be a great love story. The chemistry between the two was electrifying, and I was one of many who loved it, a whole 10 years ago (and I was only 11, go figure). It wasn't all perfect back then though. The Alfie/Little Mo love story was a bit ridiculous in all honesty, but Alfie was a single man, Kat had broken his heart trying to save him from the nutcase Andy, and he ended up with her sister.
However, in Christmas 2005 when Kat was there for Alfie following Nana's death, they both realized they did truly love each other. Little Mo gave Kat her blessing, Alfie came back for her and together they went off to see the world.
And can I just add, 2005 saw Kat break up from Alfie and be on her own. In that year, we saw her terrorize Chrissie and Sam once she found out who killed Den, as well as stand up to the Mitchell Brothers. We saw her be forced to realize that it was her sister who was the damaged one, who after being beaten and raped twice had finally found what Kat knew was a lovely man who would dote on her. This Kat, simply put, kicked arse.
Therefore, when BK announced both of them were coming back, I couldn't wait. I loved them as a kid and I was sure I'd love them as an adult. Then, they came back.
Baby swaps. Affairs. Misery. That's the Kat and Alfie of 2010-2012. I've ranted about the appalling Shagger storyline before, so I'll keep it brief here. Yes, Derek may have been the "ugliest man on the square," but, as most EE viewers and staff seem to not realize these days, it is not all about looks. The trouble was, we have no idea and never will what Kat saw in him. If they are going to shove the broken Kat and Alfie back together and even attempt to bring out the chemistry they had 10 years ago, we need a two-hander. We need Kat to explain why she did it. We need Alfie to realize that he can't stop wanting her. We need them to both be scared for Tommy. Maybe they will do this. One can only hope.
We all knew it was going to happen. And, to be fair, it does make sense. Alfie will feel betrayed, Roxy will feel torn, and Kat will be cackling in the background. This year was supposed to have redeemed her. Exactly, how? She's been wandering around the square miserable for most of it, befriending the also ruined Bianca and the thinnest pregnant woman ever Kirsty (seriously, Max is supposed to be intelligent). So, at the moment, I'm not routing for her to get her family back. That's because she's simply been ruined as a character.
We could forgive Sharon and Pat when they had their affairs. Sharon loved both brothers, but every time Grant was violent towards her she was drawn to him (I've watched the old episodes, as I was very young when this aired). Pat never stopped loving Frank. As for Kat... there was no reason for her to be with Derek other than "we need a Christmas storyline." They are relying so much on the great couple Kat and Alfie once were to facilitate their reunion when, in all honesty, it is bloody obvious more needs doing here.