Originally Posted by toon geordie:
“His interviews he gives re the North East big 2 are good but he is often all at sea when doing live reports. He covers all my side's home games (Newcastle) so I am probably more critical of him than others but he often fails to identify players. When he does get the goalscorer right you quite often dont know who has supplied the pass or how the move has built up-'its one of those?', 'the ball came in from the right/left', 'chaos in the penalty area (I dont really know what happened)'.
Hamill has been around the Championship scene long enough and has never played defence. Courtney is however definitely holding my interest one way or another!”
It might just be that because you are listening so intently to Graham Courtney that you notice his mistakes much more often than you do with any of the other reporters you hear, either on talkSPORT or elsewhere. Personally I have never noticed a great deal of factual errors or gaffs in Graham's reporting, but then as he rarely covers my team I'll be paying him as much attention as I am the majority of the other Matchday Live reporters (i.e. I'm not hanging off his every word as I might do if he was covering my club).
I can't think of any sports broadcaster that I have heard who is always word perfect and has never made the odd mistake every so often during the intensity of covering a live sporting event, something I'm sure isn't at all easy to do. I'm sure if we were listening hard enough to most radio football commentators/reporters over the course of a 90 minutes they were working on, we'd all be able to pick out the odd mistake here or there, so I think it's a bit much to continually highlight little things that one particular reporter has gotten wrong. If on Saturday Graham got one bit of team news from a club he doesn't usually cover wrong, then yes this is unfortunate, but it is not a biggie either.
I'd prefer to focus on the positives - for me Graham Courtney is one of the best regional sports correspondents around. He knows the teams on his patch and seems to have a deep knowledge of their histories and a strong connection with their present day affairs. He has an instantly recognisable voice that stands out and sounds good on the radio. He seems well liked by his colleagues, tends to work well with the pundits who join him at games and always strikes up a good rapport with the presenters he talks to when on shows like the Alan Brazil Sports Breakfast, Hawksbee & Jacobs and Kick Off. People of Graham's ilk are quintessential radio sports reporters - they represent their patches with a distinction and closeness that a person who works the length and breadth of the country and just pops up at the same game for the day couldn't possibly hope to match.