Originally Posted by Cantona07:
“Yeah, you were in the Liverpool thread slagging off Man Utd fans for being one-eyed (irony meter overload), then you go into the Arsenal thread doing the "arent Liverpool special?" routine and slagging off Chelsea (with the usual SAF reference) and now you are in the Chelsea thread acting surprised at the reaction you got, and patting people on the head who in your view are "posting sensibly" which seems to equate to "saying Liverpool are excellent". I find that fans interact sensibly most of the time when you do the same with them. Theres a good few on this thread who welcome a chat about their team and manager, but it doesnt really work if you are slagging them off in another thread.
This is why some people cant stand the thought of Liverpool winning. Its the sense of entitlement from *some* fans and this whole "arent we such a special club?" routine. Well guess what? Every football fan thinks their club is special else they wouldnt invest time and passion in being a fan. A Liverpool fan has no more special feeling about his club than a Chelsea fan or a non-league fan or anyone else. Im sure if you're married, you love your wife and think she is really special to you but that doesnt mean you feel the need to go round to your neighbours explaining why she is so much better than their wives. Then we throw in the whole "Steven Gerrard deserves a title" schtick which is rubbish and finally the "wouldnt it be appropriate on the 25th Anniversary of Hillsbourough" idea which i personally think is pretty distasteful to even attempt to link the two things. If Liverpool win the league then congrats to them and they will deserve it, and i'll be happy for some of the fans on this board in particular but for others i genuinely hope they never see another title.
Thread derailment over, i suspect this post wont last long anyway.”
Right many have asked me to analyse this so I will - altho it may take a while and I am not sure it is worth the time it will take but I will have a go - and hopefully this will be my last word on the matter.
You make it sound like I am in the habit of going into other teams threads and being provocative. Last night I was in the MUFC thread and said nothing anti MUFC in it, in the AFC thread and posted nothing anti AFC in it and in the CFC thread and posted nothing anti CFC in it - so where you get your facts from I have no idea. To illustrate this I will go over what happened last night re my posting.
I started by reading the LFC thread as I always do - there it spoke about some parts of the MUFC thread which were going into meltdown about the prospect of LFC winning the PL (or some similar phrase) so I went in it to look and for sure there were some ridiculous anti LFC posts. However I did not post in the MUFC thread picking up on any of this but went back in the LFC thread and said you had to smile at them - that's all I said. You see many MUFC fans have a pathological hatred of LFC - and LFC fans of MUFC, I recognise it works both ways and there is not a lot wrong with inter team rivalry if it is just banter and the natural football tribalism that exists. However when LFC sing re Munich, MUFC sing re Hillsborough, excrement is dropped on fans from stands above, ambulances containing badly injured players get rocked, toilets get wrecked at rivals grounds...etc that is when it has gone too far - and both sets of fans are as guilty as each other imo. But I digress. The truth is that they hate us doing so well and with how their season has gone it must be hard for them to take, its been hard for us for 24 years so to goad them further I did not think would be appropriate.
I then went into the AFC thread and saw a poster who said they wanted CFC to win the PL - which I found surprising given the way JM has treated Wenger recently with taunts re his lack of trophies and no handshake at the recent fixture - so I pointed this out - a pro AFC anti CFC view in the AFC thread which I thought would be received well. It wasn't and then a poster started getting very anti LFC and SG in particular calling him an odious toad - later he said he should have said turd. Charming I thought!! He then said how it was wrong that SG is seen as loyal given the CFC episode in 2005 giving his version of it which basically said that SG only stayed at LFC cos of money - which I felt was completely wrong so I went on to give my version which included the phrase which has been picked up a lot when I said he stayed at LFC cos in his eyes it is a special club. I said I agreed with that opinion. That was about as far as that discussion went.
Then I went into the MUFC thread again and saw a post from C07 having a go at me for saying in the AFC thread what a special club LFC was - which in no way recognised the context of why I said that - which was as above. I then did post in the MUFC thread chiding C07 by saying that his posts were developing an aggressive unfortunate style whereby they were often nasty to people like myself who always try to be fair minded - whilst obviously I never forget my LFC allegiance - but I accept my views may not always agree with him or others.
By this stage I was getting a bit fed up - so came into this thread and came across sensible posts from Dend and Richmond where they gave a fair analysis of where the PL race is up to - which I endorsed. In fact the only bit I disagreed with was where Dend said he thought CFC may lose points to Sunderland - I said I saw little likelihood of that. An attempt by me to be nice to CFC fans on their thread - but it was what I thought and still do think so why not.
Last night I also posted in the Luton promoted thread and the EFC out of the top 4 race thread - the former about my mug collection and charity trip round the 92 grounds and the latter saying what an unthinking poster the OP was - as clearly EFC are not out of the top 4 race as they are just 1 point behind AFC.
I do not think any of what I did last night in any of the threads as described here was out of order - altho maybe my description of LFC as a special club in the AFC thread could be perceived as such - but that was done to explain why SG did not join CFC but stayed at LFC in 2005.
Re the final para quoted above I have never said we deserve the title for SGs sake or worse still cos it is the 25th anniversary. We will deserve the title if we are the best team and get more points than everyone else - no other reason - at the moment we have a decent chance of that happening but that is all - a decent chance - it could go wrong in any of the 4 matches remaining so nowhere will you see me even hinting it is all over - I have seen LFC posters stating we will win the league and things like 'when' SG lifts the trophy which make me cringe and yes in doing so they are arrogant - but even more so foolish as if it goes wrong you end up with egg all over your face.
I have had my say, my right of reply if you will - and I am sorry CFC fans it is in your thread but it had to be here as C07s rant ripping me apart which several have endorsed was in here.
Maybe you all still think I am some kind of ***** - I am not expecting you to agree with me but at least now you can maybe see where I am coming from, I hope so anyway.