Originally Posted by gladiator18:
“Two unlikeable people, could play a game of whos more in love with themselves and never get a winner. One candidate who is weak while the other is a strong candidate, quite obvious which is which. One who has no business acumen and business plan spells massive risk, while the other is business minded and has been successful in every business and business plan is simple and will get results.
I will eat my hat if Luisa does not win. The most one sided final making it boring. How on earth leah is even in the final is beyond me.
Not only that but Lord Sugar wouldntve hired any of these anyway if Cloughs business plan had been good which says something about the level of these candidates.”
I cant agree with your appraisal of them. Successful in every business! What about Louisa Lingerie which we dont hear about. I am sure there could be many others. Her husband's business is also a failure which she may or may not have had a hand in.
I dont consider Leah 'weak' just not experienced. Not exactly the same thing. This massive risk you talk about can be insured against.
I would consider Leah's business plan a lot simpler, at least I even understand it. I doubt if anyone understands properly what Louisa's plan is (even herself). Who is she exactly going against, which competition? Dr Kipling someone said. It seems she will just 'muddle' through and find what the market or other bakers want. They all agreed there is a gap in the market but are not telling us exactly what it is, or dont perhaps know.
That what you say about LS is something I really cant understand. These girls all three of them have shown they can 'do' something in their life apart from just on tasks. Neil has so far to my knowledge done absolutely nothing and seems to be unemployed at the moment. How can LS just judge them on the tasks alone. Maybe tonight we will hear more about it. Neil seems never to have used his own money for anything and from his business plan seems quite free to use someone else's.
The only problem LS has with the girls is that maybe their business plans are 'too' big for them. I would agree they all are, Louisa making a new 'brand', I dont think she is up to it. I dont even know what exactly it is going to sell. Maybe on the next task we will find out. Is it a retail or wholesale brand.
Leah's plan although I am sure she has costed it to the last penny does involve people. People are always unpredictable and that is something one cannot 'cost' in advance. We have no idea how well she can manage them yet.
If I was LS I would have gone with Francesca and provided her with help. She wanted to do something she is already doing not something new and had the best and simplest plan. I blame Karren and Nick for not supporting her and I dont know yet why. Somewhere on the tasks she must have upset them. I do hope someone watching goes to her 'aid' and invests with her. I think she deserves it more than the others. She was put down terribly all along and still sailed through.