Task Evaluations
Striking while the iron is hot, ha! Firstly, I think this BR has made it seem like your team were a bit of a mess, when in reality this was not the case for the most part you worked together well. In terms of team spirit and effort, I was pleased. The two things that let you all down were the baby monitors – the other team thought outside of the box and managed to secure those for nothing, and obviously the flight fiasco. I apologise if what I said at all mislead you, I just thought return flight fairly obviously meant there-and-back and genuinely thought you were asking where the journey was supposed to start from. I was literally making
this face when I noticed your flight was only one way. You all really did make me laugh though, Katie excitedly mistaking an oven for the dishwasher, the constant Russian Doll false alarms, the flight/flights fiasco and the team's attempt to rationalise it while waiting for Louise to return - it was all super funny. Commiserations on your loss anyway, I’m not taking it as too much of a reflection on your abilities.
Justin – Well done for stepping up to be PM, this task is not easy to project manage at all - a lot of the 'strategies' you could have deployed just sort of push responsibility in other directions as opposed to being helpful for winning the task. I think you did an acceptable job considering it took so long for you to be selected. I don’t think the time difference helped you, however as PM it IS ultimately your responsibility to check for things like the flight situation. Sadly, after 3 BRs in a row, having found none of the cheapest items and being the losing PM (having not had a clear strategy in this even in terms of tactics and being able to shift blame elsewhere), there was no other option but for you to leave, however I think you’ve been a very capable candidate and I’m very sad to see you go.
Jack – Firstly, congratulations on a remarkable boardroom defense. I’m quite pleased to admit I was wrong, and that you successfully convinced me that you were correct in holding back on PMing on this task. That being said, I would like to see you project manage soon. On task I was pleased with your performance, the searching overseas suggestion was inspired, so overall a decent task for you and one I’m very sad to see you in the final 3 after. I hope we continue to see more of this sassy streak you seem to have. Also, to add in one more point, considering the sleep deprivation factor, which I was unaware of, your work today was exceptional.
Nail – As you pointed out, the responsibility for the flight scenario was not solely yours, and I’m happy to give you and the rest of the team the benefit of the doubt over the misunderstanding, so I don’t think it’s fair that the full burden has fallen on you. I was impressed by how well you led in the PM-less interim, although as I hinted I do wish you had fully taken command, however I understand your reasons for not doing so. Your work on-task was great though, well done, this task shouldn't hinder you too much in the long run.
Amy – I feel that you very much acted upon my previous feedback, and this week was the most energy and personality I’ve seen from you so far. You also did a fantastic job on-task, and very much deserved being saved from the boardroom, and like Jack I hope to see more of this fiery side. Just be sure to take credit for what you do, I noticed you said that you thought Justin should have taken you into the BR instead of Jack. I can understand your modesty, just don’t ever sell yourself short - if you don't believe in yourself, you cannot expect Louise to believe in you.
Katie – On their evaluation, another candidate said of you for the strongest candidate question: “I am sounding like a broken record but I think Katie again as she has just been brilliant on this task as she's been great on them all. Literally she's a finalist with the way she's been so consistent.” I would personally agree to this, however some also singled you out as the weakest on this task from your team, so in future ensure that everyone has equally glowing reports of you. That being said, well done on this task – I think you worked very hard and your performance in this competition is far more impressive than your win-loss ratio suggests. Also, well done on acting professional despite your issues with Justin, it's nice to see you maturing in this!