• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Big Brother
Has Callum got mental health issues?
<<
<
5 of 5
>>
>
Kaylalou
19-07-2013
Originally Posted by doop:
“There is little difference between them as far as the majority of psychiatrists are concerned, both terms come under Anti Social Personality Disorder.

There are a few psychologists who disagree and say a sociopath and psychopath are different things,different theories and opinions on the topic as you would expect.

I am not throwing out random diagnoses at all I am simply stating my opinion, based on what I`ve seen so far, if anyone is dishing out diagnoses then it is the OP who appears to be suggesting that Callum is mentally unbalanced. yet the OP has got less stick for making a thread about it and the constant threads I`ve seen on this forum calling him weird, creepy, picking on the shape of his head also and his looks, yet where were the so called Callum supporters defending him then? but because I express an opinion about the "POSIBILITY" he could I said "could" be a sociopath or have a few traits I get shot down straight away.

There is a lot of hypocrisy on this forum at times and there is also a lot of bias against certain FM`s but do I care? NOPE I couldn`t give a toss, everyone is allowed to express an opinion as long as they are not trolling or inciting hatred or using hate speech.

For your information and BelindaJ, I actually like Callum now even though I cannot fully work him out, I have expressed many times this week in many threads that Callum has been growing on me as an housemate and have expressed my dislike at the amount of Callum hate on the forum

Like I say anything is possible, I didn`t say he was definitely a sociopath and I did not diagnose anyone either

But with regards to psychopathy being considered psychosis as you pointed out, It isn`t Psychopaths are sane.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hon3AzMO6vs

This man in the video has worked with Dr Hare the world leading expert on psychopathy.”

I can tell you now, in hospitals ive worked on (im a psych nurse) there are differences. The diagnosis of antisocial is like the umberella term and obviously psychopathy is more specific. And we try to stick to an individual diagnosis as to not group them together.

But yeah, psychosis is nothing remotley like psychopathy. And again, psychopaths are not always sane. Ive nursed a handful. They can be detained and sectioned as with any other mental illness or disorder.
Blondie X
19-07-2013
Originally Posted by Stigofthedump:
“I don't see anything wrong with the guy and he certainly doesn't appear to have any form of autism. I see him get frustrated with how the group constantly perceive him since Dan got his claws into him and Jackie started to consistently badger him. Add a couple of drinks and he's acting how a lot of people would act. My estimation has gone up for him seeing how he has coped in strange and frustrating circumstances.”

I agree. I think he's had the hardest time out of anyone in there and he doesn't get what he's done wrong.

He is probably someone who is popular in his own circle and went in there expecting to be the 'good bloke' of the house. The fact he's been isolated almost since day one and is now being belittled and picked on by a sour faced old harpy for daring to be attracted to her adult daughter is doing his head in and he doesn't want to be treated the way he is being.

I think he's handling himself well in the circumstances and he definitely showed Mommy Dearest up.
Blondie X
19-07-2013
Originally Posted by wishfulthinking:
“Callum's only problem is that he is probably the most normal one in there and so doesn't fit in with all the other weirdos.

He's a bit insecure but I find that quite endearing.”

Yep, ever since about BB5, average Joes have no place in the BB house. Unless you're a fake, a loon or a desperado, you haven't got a hope in hell
Conehead
19-07-2013
I will reserve judgement until I hear him use the word "butthurt" before condemning him out of hand.
BelindaJ
19-07-2013
He is fine think the OP may have some expertise in the area it is always better if you are not medically trained as you will offer generalised tick box, text book treatment to one and all unless you are psychotic through booze.
Model_Citizen
19-07-2013
Nope he just doesnt know how to socialise in a group without being alpha male , would be interesting to see his position in his peer group
changa
19-07-2013
Originally Posted by Model_Citizen:
“Nope he just doesnt know how to socialise in a group without being alpha male , would be interesting to see his position in his peer group”

I don't see him as an alpha male at all. He's not dynamic enough
doop
19-07-2013
Originally Posted by Kaylalou:
“I can tell you now, in hospitals ive worked on (im a psych nurse) there are differences. The diagnosis of antisocial is like the umberella term and obviously psychopathy is more specific. And we try to stick to an individual diagnosis as to not group them together.

But yeah, psychosis is nothing remotley like psychopathy. And again, psychopaths are not always sane. Ive nursed a handful. They can be detained and sectioned as with any other mental illness or disorder.”

So you as a nurse go against what the leading expert on the personality disorder Dr Robert Hare the one who created the psychopathy checklist used by mental health professionals and law enforcement agencies around the world? the one who has dedicated decades of his life to the disorder of psychopathy?

Some psychopaths may not be sane if they have other disorders on top of their psychopathy, it is possible and to have psychopathy and a form of psychosis together.

But in general the majority of highly functioning psychopaths are pretty sane individuals.

Your opinion that sociopath and psychopath are not the same goes against what many of the high ranked professionals have to say on the matter.

Besides you cannot cure psychopathy using psychiatric treatments, people attempted this decades ago and It didn`t work at all.

Psychopathy is now believed by neurologists and psychologists to be something to do with how the brain functions, the part that controls emotions, empathy and conscience doesn`t work properly according to the most recent research carried out by experts including Dr Hare.
Kaylalou
19-07-2013
Originally Posted by doop:
“So you as a nurse go against what the leading expert on the personality disorder Dr Robert Hare the one who created the psychopathy checklist used by mental health professionals and law enforcement agencies around the world? the one who has dedicated decades of his life to the disorder of psychopathy?

Some psychopaths may not be sane if they have other disorders on top of their psychopathy, it is possible and to have psychopathy and a form of psychosis together.

But in general the majority of highly functioning psychopaths are pretty sane individuals.

Your opinion that sociopath and psychopath are not the same goes against what many of the high ranked professionals have to say on the matter.

Besides you cannot cure psychopathy using psychiatric treatments, people attempted this decades ago and It didn`t work at all.

Psychopathy is now believed by neurologists and psychologists to be something to do with how the brain functions, the part that controls emotions, empathy and conscience doesn`t work properly according to the most recent research carried out by experts including Dr Hare.”

Please dont patronise me by telling me stuff yoy learn in first year at uni surrounding personality disorders.

I go by our psychaitrists. And we go by indivdual diagnoses as do most trusts. And we dont group them together. We saw a chart similar to this whist studying pd. http://redicecreations.com/article.php?id=23957

Its possible to be detained on a personality disorder alone umder the ammendment in the mha. you dont need a psychotic illness to be detained.

But obviously you know my job better than me.
Kaylalou
19-07-2013
And for the record, I know about Hare, I really dont need you to attempt to educate me on my job, trust me we've done all of this lol. But honestly, a hell of a lot of psychiatrists think there's a difference between the two, or at least some notable (in our trust anyway). But then I get the impression from your wording I'm "just a nurse" so my opinion based on professional experiences is irrelevant anyway so I might as well not bother.
whatever54
19-07-2013
He comes across to me as one of the sanest people in there. I love that he ensures Sam isn't excluded, he was good in the task. I like him and will be a Traversty if he goes and sour faced harridan stays.
hrh7
19-07-2013
Originally Posted by 0pinionated:
“Yeah but the 'soar' and 'ask me how I am?' were extremely creep moments..”

Not creepy this bit at least, but more what Linus says below, that's how I read it

Originally Posted by Linus2:
“He is not putting on an act he just wanted to talk to someone who is not a hm. The DR always asks when someone is coming in "how are you" so he probably wanted to make sure that someone is listening before he started talking.”

Rosie50
19-07-2013
Originally Posted by bill deburg:
“People are too quick to apply labels for things in relation to mental health. The guy is just trying to deal with a stressful situation and isnt the greatest at expressing himself.”

I Couldn't agree more bill
Rosie50
19-07-2013
Originally Posted by doop:
“So you as a nurse go against what the leading expert on the personality disorder Dr Robert Hare the one who created the psychopathy checklist used by mental health professionals and law enforcement agencies around the world? the one who has dedicated decades of his life to the disorder of psychopathy?

Some psychopaths may not be sane if they have other disorders on top of their psychopathy, it is possible and to have psychopathy and a form of psychosis together.

But in general the majority of highly functioning psychopaths are pretty sane individuals.

Your opinion that sociopath and psychopath are not the same goes against what many of the high ranked professionals have to say on the matter.

Besides you cannot cure psychopathy using psychiatric treatments, people attempted this decades ago and It didn`t work at all.

Psychopathy is now believed by neurologists and psychologists to be something to do with how the brain functions, the part that controls emotions, empathy and conscience doesn`t work properly according to the most recent research carried out by experts including Dr Hare.”

Phew I Thought this was a BB forum not a medical academy I must be in the wrong forum please Sore me back to BB :
Peter E
30-07-2013
Just seen the live feed from last night. The guy is clearly not right and needs help. Anyone who has seen last nights live feed and thinks he's normal si living in denial. He's very controlling and possessive towards Charlie. This in addition to his behaviour over the past few weeks is very worrying!!
farlofan
30-07-2013
Originally Posted by Peter E:
“Just seen the live feed from last night. The guy is clearly not right and needs help. Anyone who has seen last nights live feed and thinks he's normal si living in denial. He's very controlling and possessive towards Charlie. This in addition to his behaviour over the past few weeks is very worrying!!”

I'm glad you know what is normal and that you're qualified to judge when someone needs help.
Seymour
30-07-2013
I have no idea if Callum is normal or not, what I do think is that being on BB will not have helped him much, he seem to be under great pressure trying his hardest to be accepted by the other hm's and imo failing.. I would really like him to see Dexter off , but I doubt it will happen...
Cassy990
30-07-2013
He is an intense person, desperate to be liked, trying to impress a girl who is just not interested. He goes on with a few drinks but he isn't mental.
He has come in for as rough a time as any of them with the housemates, Dexter (who I like) being the ringleader and them all following him with the exception of Gina and Sam. He's done well to keep his temper imo.
Silver-Fox
30-07-2013
Originally Posted by Peter E:
“His behaviour over the past week and especailly last night hass been very alarming!!

This is not a ''bash Callum thread'' but I'm geninely considered for the guy's state of mind.

His behavour in the Diary Room ''ask me how I am?'' was very strange and he has a tendency to repeat sentences over and over again.

Does anyone think Callum has got mental health issues?”

NO. He is playing the game along with everyone else.
Val_Beam
30-07-2013
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y32ExywVQ5M
mickmercer
30-07-2013
I don't think he has mental issues, just emotional ones, which sway how he feels, then behaves. His worst problem is the verbal diarrhea.
<<
<
5 of 5
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map