Originally Posted by seansnotmyname@:
“Bollox, the fact we drew at Old Trafford was a massive news story at the time.
Of course Robbie's use of it is odd, but he did winky-face.”
Sssh, you're not supposed to mention who Exeter were playing!
Originally Posted by C14E:
“But I don't think it mattered what they did, music was never going to work.”
There was a piece in The Guardian the other week about pop on TV to coincide with this show. I'd love there to be a music show on primetime TV, I still think it's totally bizarre how there are two hugely hyped shows on primetime TV which attempt to try and find new pop stars, and the likes of Lady Gaga are all over the papers, yet apparently pop music has no chance of succeeding on TV.
The piece mentioned the best places to launch bands now are Soccer AM and Saturday Kitchen and certainly there's an obvious gap to be filled in between the snoozesome Later and the showcases for established stars. The piece mentioned CDUK as a great show and certainly in its pomp it was very influential and got plenty of support from the industry because its scheduling meant it was a very important way to attract the audience they wanted. But the revamp in 2005 ruined it, then of course Channel Five bought it but it never happened, and ITV planned a replacement but couldn't find a sponsor so abandoned it.
Originally Posted by
Pizzatheaction:
“To save you asking again if it becomes ten in a row next week (
), I think E'dale was ahead, excluding 'Enders omnibus (and often including it) for about six months in 1985. By summer 1985, EastEnders was down to 10.6m including the omnibus, which was far from great for the mid-1980s. EastEnders didn't take off until it moved from 7pm to 7.30pm in September 1985.”
Indeed, the idea was that it would pull in big audience when Emmerdale had gone off for the summer as it usually did, but ITV countered that by, funnily enough, not taking it off for the summer. Not sure why the Beeb didn't expect that. And Emmerdale has been on all year round since.
Originally Posted by guestofseth:
“I Love My Country was no worse (or better) than Splash, a bit of harmless fluff not trying to be anything else, probably won't watch it again but it was overly awful. Of course it will be called the worst thing ever/not bad depending on channel affiliation (the negative side are always more hyperbolic).”
Much of the ire on Twitter of course comes from people who slag off all Saturday night light entertainment, assuming that if we didn't have it we would get Breaking Bad on a Saturday night or something. I think only Ally Ross of all the TV critics actually spot the difference between good light entertainment and bad light entertainment. As has been said, light entertainment has always been that, light. There's a couple of complete House Partys on YouTube and last night I ended up watching the episode from Boxing Day 1992, famously its most successful episode ever which absolutely thrashed ITV (and at the end Noel twice points out that Last of the Summer Wine is next) and one of the main items is Joe Longthorne singing with a dog.
Originally Posted by C14E:
“It also goes against the argument that people are willing to try out new BBC entertainment series. I think there's an older audience always willing to try a lottery quiz show with Nick Knowles or something very homely with John Barrowman. But when you produce something that's not tailored to that audience, the numbers don't come in. Gabby Logan and Frank Skinner in a rowdy panel show don't have that appeal for BBC1.”
Yes, I think this was always going to be an acquired taste. Robbie's reference to Night Fever isn't a bad one, I actually thought it felt a bit like this, and I do think the relentless silliness and cheerfulness is going to put a lot of people off. You can give it credit for at least trying to make a panel show format suitable for Saturday primetime but it is going to turn some people off immediately because it's so brash. Can't imagine what it would have been like with David Walliams.
The bits I liked about it are a) Frank Skinner, who is always great, and I like how he recycled his old Anne and Nick routine, as seen on Fantasy Football in 1996, for Susannah Reid, b) Jamelia, who I've always liked, c) the fact it's got a band perfoming the theme tune to The Challenge Programme, as Anneka called it and d) the parcel exploding with obviously more force than they expected it to. By the way, it's not me who was the Script Associate. in case anyone who read the credits was reading.
Originally Posted by
RobbieSykes123:
“Though it did give me chance to enjoy the "tenor who says wank" sketch. I remember that being the talk of the common room the day after it first aired.
”
Indeed, that made my cry with laughter first time round. It was actually the first sketch ever sold by Graham Linehan and Arthur Mathews, as can be seen by the fact it's clearly a Big Train sketch six years early.
Originally Posted by Zac Quinn:
“As soon as you start changing the tone of a show which has been set up like that, putting more emphasis on the 'result' as opposed to the 'fun', people can no longer watch it as a bit of nonsense on a Saturday, it becomes an X Factor which attempts to take over your lives, and I'm not sure people would be that interested if this became the show where they felt forced to care about "which dropped soap actor do the anonymous general public find least entertaining under the guise of a pop star from 40 years ago". To reiterate, I haven't seen much comment on this show, but quite a proportion of what I did see about it specifically levelled criticism at Aleesha for taking the show too seriously as host. That says to me that, if ITV switched the focus to a weekly elimination format which is by default more tense and shouty about how "you must care about this show and think about it during the week", folks would be put off.”
I loved this post, the bits in bold really tickled me. I think that's exactly right and that's why I didn't care for Splash, the second you start putting voting in it you're taking it too seriously. Too many shows these days think they matter. It's a bit like on Celebrity Fame Academy, when everyone cried and booed the judges, who cared? Far better when they replaced it with Let's Dance where nobody gives a toss, the judges mess around and everyone knows it means absolutely nothing in the grand scheme of things.
Originally Posted by H of De Vil:
“Anything with The National Lottery in front of it seems to be garunteed a 4million+ audience”
Apart from the actual draws themselves, of course, which is why they don't do them on Wednesdays and Fridays anymore, and why when they're on their own they rate very poorly. And of course there have been a lot of lottery quizzes that haven't rated, like This Time Tomorrow and Millionaore Manor.
Break The Safe is certainly becoming highly entertaining in terms of stupid answers, though. Can't decide if my favourite last night was the suggestion George Osborne was preceded as Chancellor by George Osborne or that Craig Charles' character in Red Dwarf was called Hitler.
Originally Posted by Zac Quinn:
“I have no idea, does it? Even so, S4C isn't a new sports channel needing to prove that it's worth £15 a month, S4C isnt a new sports channel trying desperately hard to shout about it's credibility - and, perhaps most importantly, S4C isn't a new sports channel that wants so desperately to be seen as a serious challenger to Sky where Setanta and ESPN tried and utterly failed to take off. Like I said, for the amount of money they'll have paid to show the rights, paying for a blank screen would be better value for money than programming which attracts sub-1000 viewers.”
But there's loads on Sky that gets no viewers, like all those minority sports they put on. Things like showjumping, netball and that on Sky Sports get low ratings as well. They inherited the UFC from ESPN so they probably paid next to nothing for it and then it's two in the morning as well.
Obviously in their early days BT are going to promote their stuff more extensively, they gave the Liverpool friendly yesterday 75 minutes of build-up and had all their big names on it. In a few years time they'll be doing what Sky do and just get Tony Jones to present and commentate from a cupboard.
Originally Posted by RobInnes:
“I read somewhere that some ridiculously trashy dating show in the 90s on Channel 5 got exactly 0 viewers. I don't know how true it is though.”
William Phillips in Broadcast once did a list of all the occasions a terrestrial channel got a rating under 250,000 in primetime, it was in around 1999. On Christmas Day 1993 both BBC2 and Channel Four got a zero rating in primetime, BBC2 got it for Selected Exits, a one-act play starring John Geilgud and directed by Kenneth Branagh. Can't remember what C4's zero rating was for but I do know that, as the Radio Times Guide to TV Comedy points out, three days later they got 235,000 at 10pm for an imported Tim Allen stand-up special, before Toy Story and Home Improvement when nobody knew who he was.
It used to be that under 200k was zero because at that point the margin of error made it impossible to judge. I know RI:SE used to get zero quite a bit at 7am.