Originally Posted by AcerBen:
“May be true that TOTP would be less important than it was, but that doesn't mean there's no need for it. Watching music videos on your laptop is not the same as watching live performances on TOTP. By that logic, we don't need Glastonbury on TV either, or any music at all.
If TOTP had the right person in charge, they put enough money into it and got the biggest acts on week after week, and they put it somewhere it wasn't up against an ITV soap (difficult but Wednesday 8pm would work) I believe it could get 4 million viewers. On a good week IIRC it got 3 million in its last few months on BBC One, and that was when it was against Corrie and the singles chart was in a right mess.
One thing I never understood was how the BBC didn't make enough money out of the TOTP brand to make it not matter about the ratings - it was sold all over the world.
The Jimmy Savile thing could be a problem, but it doesn't stop them doing the Christmas shows and 1978 repeats.”
TOTP is IMO not worth reviving, its like Woolworths, something we fondly remember, but dont actually shop their, sure we all went to the closing down sales, and left disappointed by the rubbish that was on offer, in the process remembering why we didnt shop their anymore.
TOTP now would be rubbish, for two reasons
1) music is bland, all the Syco acts could not preform a decent live version of their songs, if they careers depended up on it. I saw Olly Murs perform Dance with Me Tonight, on one of the TOTP Christmas episodes, and whilst the radio edit of the song, was "not in anywhere objectionable" bordering on "Steering wheel tapping" his performance was dreadful.
2) international artists, it is great that the UK charts, have music from all over the world in it (even if alot of it is very commercial) , but those international acts wont set foot in the UK, yet alone agree to appear on TOTP.
Then there are other factors such as the basic format, the countdown of the weeks top 10, and 95% of the performances coming from the Top 20 is very limiting as to what can be aired, to say nothing of those acts, are basically Syco puppets, good for nothing but earning Simon Cowell money, hardly worthy of BBC airtime.
Sure the BBC can celebrate music, but it needs to create events, not just mimed performances of songs you hear on your radio, or whos videos can be viewed on YouTube. It needs to create unique performances, thins that in this modern day, will be shared over the internet, something that the artists involved will never do again. The best music feature ive seen/heard on the BBC in years was John Holmes "His Buskers Voice", and whilst that may not work on telly, the spirit is everything that TOTP needs to be, but could never be.