This is just an idea for a thread that came up

We've had 4 judging panels:

Simon, Amanda, Piers (2007-2010)
David Hassellhoff, Amanda, Michael Mcintyre (2011)
Simon, David Hassellhoff, Amanda, Michael Mcintyre (2011)
Simon, Amanda, Alesha, David (2012 - )

Which is your favourite and why? Me I like the current one, they've all got great chemistry and David is hilarious :P

I can't seem to add a poll to this...:/

Go to Threat Tools and click 'Add a Poll to this thread'.

The current one is definitely the best.

The first one, the new one was decent at first but it's getting stale, change the female judges for Geri Halliwell & Carmon Electra & since there very popular keep the current judges

Peter Kay-Mel b-Dawn French-Simon

Now that would be a great panel

Simon, Amanda, Alesha, David are by far the best. All of them are entertaining in their own way!

The one we have now is definitely the best.

Wouldn't mind them replacing Amanda though.

I feel the panel needs a change. Keep Simon and Alesha. Get rid of Amanda and David. I would replace them with Danni M and John bishop.

David is contracted for 2014

I think any panel would work with david Walliams in it. He's the best thing that ever happened to that show!

yeah bring dannii on it

Agreed. I wouldn't mind her replacing Amanda!

I'd love to see David's jokes if Danniii was on

Me too. Hes said some things about her so it would be wonderfully awkward to see her next to him
Shes not like Simon and I bet she would turn it around being the one with the gaydar,sitting on his lap etc.

We have our peak judging panel currently so defiantly this one. The only thing that would make it better would be to have Michael McIntyre on as a fifth judge.

Having Walliams in a show tht has the word 'talent' in the title seems to be somewhat contradictory.


A man of limited talent in many ways; and being on any panel is probably his weakest poit.

No doubt we shall all be treated to his inanities and puerile 'jokes'.


He was excruciatingly awful on a recent showing of 'Catchphrase', absolutely awful.


The bottom of the barrel has been well and truly scraped.

I like the current panel. David and Simon make it worth watching. If anything had to change I'd probably replace Amanda with somebody a little less vacant, but I don't really mind her.

I liked Michael McIntyre, with Simon and Amanda, I would replaces Alisha with David Walliams!