Originally Posted by DUNDEEBOY:
“Think the real issues are he persists with the same old players despite multiple tournament failures .
We are very close to being able to field a team of 30 somethings .
Fielding players who aren't fit or haven't seen club action for months , he said this was going to stop but it's not. This is now championship level players who are not getting selected by their clubs.
The ignoring of spfl players outwith Celtic who are in form
The calling up of complete randoms because they are a big lad etc and then never seen again.
Players playing at u21 level not being allowed to progress
This will end the Craig brown way where the team was about 35 and they all needing to be replaced at once and no one to replace, yet vogts got the blame for this”
I agree there are many duds or older players who should be cut out - Gordon, McGregor, Greer, Whittaker, Hutton, McArthur, Dorrans, Adam, McCormack guys who are old or who have been about for a long time without making the XI.
Mulgrew, Brown, D.Fletcher, Morrison, Naismith and S.Fletcher are probably still needed though because theres not much other options in their positions.
Only problem is there isn't that many good younger players to actually get a game, Tierney could play right-back even though he's left footed unorthodox but it could work. McGinn should stay around the team, hes a solid midfielder - probably the only player in Scotland I would sign for Celtic.
Liam Henderson is promising but still needs a full season at Celtic or in the SPL or a decent League to prove himself more. Other than them I can't think of anyone decent or deserving of a game. There's Tony Watt as well although he needs to screw the nut, I could imagine him being a good Scotland striker though, quick, strong, skillful but he could also not amount to much as he seems a bit wild and stupid off the park.
Also Gauld and Christie who look to have very good talent technically, watched the U21 game the other day and Christie played very well, not really kicked a ball for Celtic yet same with Gauld at Sporting.
Maybe could include players like Tierney, Henderson, McGinn, Christie, Gauld and Watt in the squads all the time though not as if there would be any harm in leaving out guys like Cooper, Whittaker, Bridcutt, Dorrans, Forrest, McCormack, C.Martin and guys like that who've done nothing and don't get a game anyway