I agree with you Scrabbler. Besides killing a woman would not make Carl a touch guy. IMO men should pick on someone their own size.
I'd say that either his brother is holding her or he has frightened her off by threatening Carly and Jimmy, much like he frightened Max into lying. He could have easily found out about them by going through Shirley's bags.

You said ass

Typo

Don't know if this has already been mentioned but Inside Soap had pics of Max and Phil shooting a kdnap scene with Carl. I'm hoping Shirl makes her reappearance in order to free Max

I agree. If he had killed her that easily then why wouldn't he just do away with Ronnie too.

He's clearly just frightened her off which quite honestly she deserves just for her stupidity of wading in when she really shouldn't have.

Why steal the money and book a plane ticket and hire a cab and say goodbye and then return just to sit in the Arches and catch out a nasty villain

The point I was making was that your views about Shirley seem quite extreme, considering she's just a lazy joke character. I just don't see it.
Someone here even used the term Voyeuristic sadist.
You said yourself you were being deadly serious.
No one is trying to curb freedom of expression, but it's OK to challenge one another.

This.

Except it isn't ok to challenge one another. We are supposed to discuss the characters not posters. You can disagree with mo's interpretation of Shirley but not question his character for thinking that

It was the comment about the character that isnt real they were commenting on

What about all the people who were calling Mona a child abusing freak over her opinion on the chair kicking incident?

Also, I thought Mo was female, but then I'm not even sure...

I didnt even know that but i think it been proved denny was doing it on purpose

Mo mouse is male I think.

Ive seen her about on twitter, pretty sure shes female

I think you need to re-read the thread. The poster was questioning mo's character for thinking what he thinks about a fictional character. mo is a poster and we shouldn't be discussing posters.


I'm not sure what you mean because someone did this to another poster it's fair game. We are discussing character's in soaps not members of the forum.

I understand mo is male

^ as far as ive seen on twitter shes female.


thats what i mean, the comment was about a fictional character and we thought it was too much

I hope not. That sort of thing creeps me out.

I'm glad you aknowledge it's not fair game. As long as people see that.

It's because the character is fictional that posters can say what they like. It's real people like posters on here that you cannot say what you like.


Why

What are you talking about?


Why wouldn't I I think the point is if you know that people shouldn't be saying what you're suggesting they did about mona then why do you talk about another poster's character.

I get that a lot but those kind of things are just too much.

Because of the Voyeuristic sadist comment earlier by another poster. That sort of thing really creeps me out.

I agree.

I dont want nightmares lol

In your opinion.


You and the other poster seem to be muddling up real life with a soap. We are talking about made up characters and as such just about anything goes. How do you feel about the writers and producers if Shirley has been murdered Or are they allowed such extreme views and opinions.

I can't stress enough that this is a soap and we are talking about the characters in a soap.

Moving onto a much more serious note:

http://www.turboimagehost.com/p/1665...oster.jpg.html