Originally Posted by mmpfb:
“Yeah I saw from the Luke thread you were pissed off about it. I kind get it, as I'd probably be pissed off if they did it to one of the songs Nicky performed (unless it was something shit like Greatest Day, Sam B can holler theatrically all over that as much as she likes as long as I don't have to pretend it's anything other than technically impressive).”
I still love Patti-Ann's suggestion of Candy, I'd probably pay to see the three boys take the piss out of that actually


Quote:
“I imagine Luke will still be doing the chorus, i.e. the anthemic bit which suits him very well, and maybe the others will take a verse each or something (as those bits seemed like they were at the very edge of his range in the final).”
I realised it pushed his range a bit, but I also thought it suffered from the shit sound production the entire final had (well the first night, I didn't really watch the second night because sulking). It's just that it was the one thing I associate with him for the final, and it's a shame it's being hijacked. I can live with it if it's Sam C though, and tbh I'm sure it is.
Quote:
“I don't know what the thinking might be, in all honesty. But I'm sure it can't be Sam B who's doing it with them. It surely must be Sam C. It would just be too incongruous for a 35 year old woman who looks ten years older to be singing/tedioulsy riffing about being young while wearing an 80s jumpsuit and brandishing her camel-toe.”
God, there's a quote that'll live with me forever

Mind you, I could watch a gif of her lumbering down that fireman's pole for hours.
Yes yes, *bitch face*, meh /care
Quote:
“If Nicky, Luke and Sam B were to do a song together it would make much more sense for it to be that Naughtyboy song they did at the start of the final. That worked well for all of them.”
That would make a lot of sense, it worked very well and was actually really surprisingly well chosen.
Maybe that's where the confusion's come in: Luke, Nicky and Sam B are doing that song again, and then the three boys are doing We Are Young. That would make sense?