Originally Posted by stargirl1:
“I think a big part of her problem is that she isn't a songwriter, and has to rely on other people to give her songs. That's fine if you're Rihanna or Beyonce and people are lining up to give you their best material, but Alex obviously isn't getting offered good songs if this latest one is anything to go by. I know she wrote WMCB on the last album but that didn't exactly display great songwriting skills.”
True. However, that song was written when she was 18. Now I started writing when I was 17 and the songs then were dirge, I'm 21 now and have been writing since and the stuff is considerably better. If she kept writing in private, getting advice etc, she could easily come up with a good song with the help of a co-writer, I mean she had the contacts.
Elton John warned her and Leona years ago about the situation they're in now, because they were so talented, and could be great. And he was right.
The biggest issue with that song was the production for me, it was basic and hollow (and sadly she's followed the trail of that song with the EP and this new song). I liked the opening line from WMCB, it worked really well as an opener + closer.
The EP had potential in places too, if that was the demo work, it could have been great...with bigger production. It's like she's lacking the right producers, because the style isn't even the problem, it's the production. I don't get why she hasn't researched proper people...or maybe she did and they didn't want to work with her.