Merry Christmas everyone.
Just reading through the thread and my (probably unpopular) opinion on 'shine' and 'NMY' is that, worst case scenario, NMY would be the single choice and best case scenario, neither. I just don't think either stand out enough or have single quality, most certainly not as a launch single for a new artist anyway. Of course, Kevin and Jojo have boatloads of experience between them and we're just going to have to trust them but honestly, I think the snippets just sound a bit dull and like they are not playing to Alex's strengths. This is why I would have preferred at least a mid-tempo song or preferably, an uptempo 'crazy in love' or 'one-thing' type song that would showcase her singing and dancing talents whilst maintaining the flexibility to switch it down to an acoustic version that will showcase her vocals. Even when Alex sang 'Listen' and to a lesser extent, 'hallelujah' on xfactor, it was so charged it made people pay attention. These snippets sound like expertly & technically perfect sung songs but nothing else.
I am holding out hope that these are just snippets and opinions could change when whole song(s) premiers. But my honest opinion, I am worried that it will not be enough to make people sit up and pay attention when she hits the US.