Originally Posted by
sofakat:
“Is there really any point wistfully wishing for all of these tracks when we all know - or ought to by now - that the band couldn't cope with them?
”
Some of the choices suggested are tunes people "like" without any regard to their suitability for dance.
As I and others have stated, the musicians employed are in reality the same as there would be in an original "Dance Band." The difference being the "big bands" of yesteryear usually only had one or two singers, where to cope the the extraordinary number of tunes used which require vocals, the SCD band have four.
In the days of the "big bands" there would be far more tunes played without vocals, as the music was more for dancing, not for "standing and watching." Though this sometimes happened with numbers with vocals.
The musicians and singers are very competent and get a ridiculously short time to learn a complete raft of tunes each week.
I don't expect the singers to be able to replicate live, what contemporary singers can produce in a studio, given I don't know how many takes and how much over-dubbing and digital enhancements are employed.
I blame the producer for some daft choices, the only reason for them is to attract a younger audience away from X-Factor.
Back on topic.
Leaving the uptempo numbers apart, which I enjoy as much as anyone, what I think works best are the romantic songs of any era where the dancing combined with an emotive tune, provides a more enjoyable experience for the viewer.
To this end, I'd suggest this, one of the most recorded "love songs" over the last half a century.
It would complement and enhance any slow tempo performance.
The band would have no problems with it at all.
I've chosen this particular recording, as I like this rendition.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EDOmq...mment_received