• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • The X Factor
Melanie McCabe is Overrated on this forum!
<<
<
4 of 5
>>
>
buckybadger
01-10-2013
Originally Posted by CJM91:
“They gush over loads of mediocre contestants. I struggle to believe you havnt yet noticed this.”

Yes I've noticed this. Tamera has given two sub-par live performances (that's two for two but who's counting) yet she is also being edited as a front-runner. She will be the one to be given chance after chance to prove herself in the live shows in spite of shouty, off-tune singing and boring, predictable song choices. I feel the same way about Sam Callahan and I'm still scratching my head over what they see in Luke. Don't get me started on the groups.

The only acts that have impressed me each time they have performed so far are Sam Bailey, Hannah and Melanie.
Eurostar
01-10-2013
Originally Posted by buckybadger:
“Yes I've noticed this. Tamera has given two sub-par live performances (that's two for two but who's counting) yet she is also being edited as a front-runner. She will be the one to be given chance after chance to prove herself in the live shows in spite of shouty, off-tune singing and boring, predictable song choices. I feel the same way about Sam Callahan and I'm still scratching my head over what they see in Luke. Don't get me started on the groups.

The only acts that have impressed me each time they have performed so far are Sam Bailey, Hannah and Melanie.”

I think the producers have latched onto Tamera primarily because of her looks and think they can mould her into a new Rihanna (but are in danger of putting the cart before the horse....having to over-hype a contestant from the outset is a bad sign and rarely if ever results in an XF winner).
abrightyz
02-10-2013
Originally Posted by Eurostar:
“I think the producers have latched onto Tamera primarily because of her looks and think they can mould her into a new Rihanna (but are in danger of putting the cart before the horse....having to over-hype a contestant from the outset is a bad sign and rarely if ever results in an XF winner).”


to think that "ella" was only last year...
researchshirley
02-10-2013
Originally Posted by buckybadger:
“Just the opposite. Melanie is underrated on this forum. Everywhere else Melanie is considered a front-runner. It's only here that there are a dispropportionate number of comments stating that she is "average", "ordinary", "underwhelming", etc. You would think by reading this forum that the producers and judges aren't listening to the same performer when they gush over her.”

"Everywhere else"? I think that very unlikely.
jerefprdterra
02-10-2013
Originally Posted by Eurostar:
“I think the producers have latched onto Tamera primarily because of her looks and think they can mould her into a new Rihanna (but are in danger of putting the cart before the horse....having to over-hype a contestant from the outset is a bad sign and rarely if ever results in an XF winner).”

They realise that Tamera has great potential which is why she is fav with the bookies.
Nastyman69
02-10-2013
Originally Posted by jerefprdterra:
“They realise that Tamera has great potential which is why she is fav with the bookies.”

You know what jeref? Tamera being bookies favourite might go against her as pressure might take its toll on a 16 year old. I would prefer if she wasn't a favourite at all. I'll be more than happy if Melanie was the favourite .
Nevertheless, you can't knock this young girl's amazing talent - my predicted winner, of course
quasimoron
02-10-2013
Originally Posted by jerefprdterra:
“They realise that Tamera has great potential which is why she is fav with the bookies.”

I don't rate her at all,a loose cannon, history of bullying and just more warbling and screeching. Like listening to a cat caught in a gate.:yawn:
Hannah is the best singer of the final girls.
jerefprdterra
02-10-2013
Hannah and Tamera are the two best singers without a doubt. I dont bother about the contestants private lives. i just judge them on their singing ability.
davedub
02-10-2013
Originally Posted by Rob200696:
“I seriously don't get the love, she sings like very note has been written down for her there is no passion,emotion or personality there at all! Her voice is good but it's not anything different or better than Leona or Alexandra!”

agreed ( well apart from alexandra ) Melanie is a lovely singer but not as great as people are making her out to be
Nastyman69
02-10-2013
Originally Posted by jerefprdterra:
“Hannah and Tamera are the two best singers without a doubt. I dont bother about the contestants private lives. i just judge them on their singing ability.”

THIS!!
quasimoron
02-10-2013
Originally Posted by jerefprdterra:
“Hannah and Tamera are the two best singers without a doubt. I dont bother about the contestants private lives. i just judge them on their singing ability.”

Me too and I don't rate Tamera or Abby, JMo.
jjbir
02-10-2013
Originally Posted by jerefprdterra:
“Hannah and Tamera are the two best singers without a doubt. I dont bother about the contestants private lives. i just judge them on their singing ability.”

Well if that is true then there truely is no talent left. I agree with you that Hannah is good, and may even be great someday. But, Tamera has been awful in her two performances, I don't agree with you that she has been better than any of the four other girls @ judges houses. I don't know if its nerves or she simply doesn't have the vocal talent, but she @ this moment in time is definately not among the two best singers. I don't think any counter argument could dissuade me from my opinion, its very clear to me that there is no evidence to suggest otherwise.IMO.
jerefprdterra
02-10-2013
Originally Posted by jjbir:
“Well if that is true then there truely is no talent left. I agree with you that Hannah is good, and may even be great someday. But, Tamera has been awful in her two performances, I don't agree with you that she has been better than any of the four other girls @ judges houses. I don't know if its nerves or she simply doesn't have the vocal talent, but she @ this moment in time is definately not among the two best singers. I don't think any counter argument could dissuade me from my opinion, its very clear to me that there is no evidence to suggest otherwise.IMO.”

We will just have to wait and see what happens.
quasimoron
02-10-2013
Originally Posted by jjbir:
“Well if that is true then there truely is no talent left. I agree with you that Hannah is good, and may even be great someday. But, Tamera has been awful in her two performances, I don't agree with you that she has been better than any of the four other girls @ judges houses. I don't know if its nerves or she simply doesn't have the vocal talent, but she @ this moment in time is definately not among the two best singers. I don't think any counter argument could dissuade me from my opinion, its very clear to me that there is no evidence to suggest otherwise.IMO.”

I agree she has been woeful and I think may cause trouble backstage when the tension rises. The girl is not ready yet in any way. Abby is just drippy and boring, a neutered, plainer kate Bush.
researchshirley
02-10-2013
Originally Posted by quasimoron:
“I agree she has been woeful and I think may cause trouble backstage when the tension rises. The girl is not ready yet in any way. Abby is just drippy and boring, a neutered, plainer kate Bush.”

I like Abi, she's much more interesting than Melanie (or Luna Lovegood as we call her in our house.)
jjbir
02-10-2013
Originally Posted by jerefprdterra:
“We will just have to wait and see what happens.”

Guess so, she may surprise me yet
quasimoron
02-10-2013
Originally Posted by researchshirley:
“I like Abi, she's much more interesting than Melanie (or Luna Lovegood as we call her in our house.)”

Luna was very interesting. Abi is boring , what is interesting about her, Flowers in the hair and drippy drippy drippy,mousey mousey, a poor mans Kate bush, VERY POOR.
We call her abbysmal Dismal in our house.
researchshirley
02-10-2013
Originally Posted by quasimoron:
“Luna was very interesting. Abi is boring , what is interesting about her, Flowers in the hair and drippy drippy drippy,mousey mousey, a poor mans Kate bush, VERY POOR.
We call her abbysmal Dismal in our house.”

Your house sounds like one long LOL.
quasimoron
02-10-2013
Originally Posted by researchshirley:
“Your house sounds like one long LOL.”

Hardly with this years xfactor, at least Rylan was funny.
researchshirley
02-10-2013
Originally Posted by quasimoron:
“Hardly with this years xfactor, at least Rylan was funny.”

It does look like it will be a fun-free year. We just have to hope someone gets through that is bad in a funny way, like Danyl and the tubby one from Little Mix.
Singy Thingy
02-10-2013
While I think a few others have more outstanding voices(Sam,Hannah, possibly collectively the new girl band, and the Sottish guy who's name escapes me atm stood out IMO), I give her a lot of credit. She doesn't give up, and she seems like she has the potential to achieve something if given the chance.

Also, I saw this when I checked out a link given here. She can sing with passion , and sound unique. We just haven't seen that in the editing on the show so far.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zyZ0DJl46iQ

Watch this, then say she is overrated. Granted, not a very challenging song for a good vocalist with a solid range to manage, but the point is, she more than managed , and I didn't find myself comparing her to Leona's beautiful rendition.
Eve Elle
02-10-2013
Reckon the OP has an overrated opinion of themselves if they believe they're "special" enough to try and tell everyone else what to think or who to like/dislike. I mean, seriously...
Eurostar
02-10-2013
Originally Posted by quasimoron:
“Luna was very interesting. Abi is boring , what is interesting about her, Flowers in the hair and drippy drippy drippy,mousey mousey, a poor mans Kate bush, VERY POOR.
We call her abbysmal Dismal in our house.”

I suspect Abi's image is fake. There are videos of her from earlier this year on Youtube looking confident, chic and stylish. Lo and behold she shows up on X factor as a geeky hippy chick with huge glasses and a flower in her hair.
jerefprdterra
02-10-2013
Originally Posted by Eurostar:
“I suspect Abi's image is fake. There are videos of her from earlier this year on Youtube looking confident, chic and stylish. Lo and behold she shows up on X factor as a geeky hippy chick with huge glasses and a flower in her hair.”

This sort of things happens on a lot of reality shows.
Eurostar
02-10-2013
Originally Posted by jerefprdterra:
“This sort of things happens on a lot of reality shows.”

Without a doubt and I don't really blame her. I smell the hand of the producers behind it (perhaps they watched her Youtube videos and earmarked her for the live shows from the outset).
<<
<
4 of 5
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map