Cant stand this girl.

2 of 3

Dave_Morris1

06-10-2013

Originally Posted by ArtemisAnimus:
“Ah, you mean Hannah. Not keen on her. It all seems a bit false when she sings. She's clever in that she knows what the judges want to see - emotion and soul - but it was very obviously overdone this episode. Seemed like she was playing a character rather than connecting with the song.

And when a child sings about wanting things to change, or how much of a struggle they've gone through it always seems a bit fake to me. Live a life and then sing about that stuff, it'll actually really mean something then.

And no, I'm not saying young people don't sometimes have pretty crappy lives (I'm sure she's probably had it tough), but the impact of a soul singer singing about struggle after a lifetime of crap is where the real powerful stuff is.”

Exactly, she's fake like Misha B was.

batesy2000

06-10-2013

Originally Posted by missbeenie:
“I would have stripped naked and run down my street and posted it on YouTube if it was a white contestant they were talking about.”

This one in particular. Sigh.

Dave_Morris1

06-10-2013

How dramatic

missbeenie

06-10-2013

Originally Posted by batesy2000:
“Was mocking that ppl (not itself) are quick to say X doesn't like Y because they're black or white. There's a lot of posts playing the race card which is silly. Reading some responses on this thread also imply she isn't liked because of her race.”

These type of posts normally only appear about black contestants or white contestants that have picked up the black vernacular.

Dave_Morris1

06-10-2013

I cant stand her because I cant stand her not because of her skin colour.

Satnavvy

06-10-2013

Why did the girl from The Voice get through?

bebop

06-10-2013

Originally Posted by DelicateKitten:
“I had to google her and discovered i only know one of her songs .... Rubbish special guest”

She's one of the greatest female vocalists of all time. She's rated up there with the greats like Aretha Franklin.

Not a rubbish guest but amazing guest.

Jelakins

06-10-2013

Originally Posted by missbeenie:
“I would have stripped naked and run down my street and posted it on YouTube if it was a white contestant they were talking about.”

hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha!

E05297535

06-10-2013

Here we go...the 'misha b' hate brigade is out in force tonight.
...as a certain fave didnt make it in, the daggers are out for those who did...hannah is a star in the making and she came on here to show us whats shes all about....and she has that right too!!!!

Reality Sucks

06-10-2013

Her mum chucked her out when she was 16 and she had to live in a refuge.

There's an a girl on USA X factor whose mother was murdered when she was 14, so to say that children haven't suffered enough to have soul is wrong IMO. Not everyone is lucky enough to come through childhood with stability.

Dream_catcher

06-10-2013

It was the only decision that I disagreed with Nicole on. Can't believe she put out the first girl and kept Abi in.

Dave_Morris1

06-10-2013

Originally Posted by E05297535:
“Here we go...the 'misha b' hate brigade is out in force tonight.
...as a certain fave didnt make it in, the daggers are out for those who did...hannah is a star in the making and she came on here to show us whats shes all about....and she has that right too!!!!”

lol if you are referring to Melanie then Im glad she didnt get through as she is decidedly average and should let it go.

Sorry to disapoint you but your argument doesnt stack up.

indenile

06-10-2013

Originally Posted by Dave_Morris1:
“Y'know what I mean like, like y'know?

Learn some other words arrogant little theatrical overbearing playacting madam.”

The silly cow wasn't smart enough to sort herself out some nice well-educated middle class parents who would have exposed her to a wide vocabulary and filled her with confidence.

Right, Dave?

patsylimerick

06-10-2013

Originally Posted by DelicateKitten:
“I had to google her and discovered i only know one of her songs .... Rubbish special guest”

Are you serious? I don't even particularly like r'n'b but you've never heard of Mary J Blige?

Surely, after you googled her, you realised that admitting you don't know here wasn't a great idea?

Dave_Morris1

06-10-2013

Originally Posted by indenile:
“The silly cow wasn't smart enough to sort herself out some nice well-educated middle class parents who would have exposed her to a wide vocabulary and filled her with confidence.

Right, Dave? ”

Lame.

She's obviously had a tough upbringing but that doesn't forego 100% of my patience when I hear some young people speak I'm afraid.

Get over it and drop the thinly veiled sarcasm.

erin_p

06-10-2013

I don't hear what Nicole hears when Hannah sings, I don't think she is special in any way .
I agree with her decision not to put Melanie through, another average singer and rather dated.

E05297535

06-10-2013

Originally Posted by Dave_Morris1:
“lol if you are referring to Melanie then Im glad she didnt get through as she is decidedly average and should let it go.

Sorry to disapoint you but your argument doesnt stack up.”

We agree on one thing here, at least....melanie is average....hannah is much more than average!!! My argument was never meant to stack up, I wanted to express it, as an opinion of mine!!!

Zizu58

06-10-2013

Originally Posted by DelicateKitten:
“I had to google her and discovered i only know one of her songs .... Rubbish special guest”

She's sold 50 million albums and she's a living legend .

Do some research !

Stormwave UK

06-10-2013

I thought Relley was much better on the day.

String9

06-10-2013

I think Nicole is confusing The UK with America, this Hannah girl, will be in the bottom 2 every week. They will keep saving her until they eventually can't anymore. She is not a star.

trevor tiger

06-10-2013

Originally Posted by erin_p:
“I don't hear what Nicole hears when Hannah sings, I don't think she is special in any way .
I agree with her decision not to put Melanie through, another average singer and rather dated.”

Ditto. I'd have picked Tamera and Abi but Relley rather than cry baby Hannah or dull Melanie.

misslibertine

06-10-2013

Originally Posted by DelicateKitten:
“I had to google her and discovered i only know one of her songs .... Rubbish special guest”

You are aware that whether someone is a "rubbish special guest" doesn't hinge on how many of her songs DelicateKitten has heard of, aren't you?

Mary J. Blige is a legendary vocalist. Some research into her career wouldn't harm you.

Reality Sucks

06-10-2013

Originally Posted by String9:
“I think Nicole is confusing The UK with America, this Hannah girl, will be in the bottom 2 every week. They will keep saving her until they eventually can't anymore. She is not a star.”

I disagree - she has star quality written all over her. I absolutely love her voice - she's an old soul, full of feeling.

DUNDEEBOY

06-10-2013

It was a very American choice wasn't it.

She would do well in a vote over there.

The traditional uk voter will not vote for her.

Think she may go first

Reality Sucks

07-10-2013

Originally Posted by DUNDEEBOY:
“It was a very American choice wasn't it.

She would do well in a vote over there.

The traditional uk voter will not vote for her.

Think she may go first”

All three of the girls are in the top 5 with oddschecker at the moment, so Nicole must be doing something right.

I totally disagree with you about people not voting for her. Vocally she's way ahead of the others.

2 of 3