On talent alone she definitely deserved to go through. Unfortunately the large majority of people who vote on this show don't really have the musical maturity to pick up the phone and vote for her or really understand her genre of music, so her place would just be wasted. I think she has a better chance of being successful without the show, hopefully she will begin to release music soon!

X factor seem to have a problem with any contestant that sings jazz. That's why they never put her through. She was really good.

Yes, I would have put her through. My three would have been Lorna, Zoe and Joseph based on vocals.

I liked her and would have put her through over Shelley, though I'd have put Andrea through over all five of them, so I guess she's still out.

I prefer her to Shelley any day but my answer is no.