• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • The X Factor
Who would you have put through??
RAINBOWGIRL22
07-10-2013
Seems to be a lot of disagreement with the judges choices so here is your opportunity to say who you would have put through from each group.

I actually don't think it is a terrible line-up.

I'd have had Zoe in the overs though (probably at the expense of Shelly) and I'd have had Paul instead of the one with the dirty hair.

Think the Groups were probably right, the girls I am not sure. I wouldn't have had Melanie though.... Note perfect as she is, she just left me cold!
Nastyman69
07-10-2013
Personal Choices:
Groups: Rough Copy, Miss Dynamix, Code 4
Girls:Hannah,Tamera, Reilly
Boys:Paul - the rest I don't give a damn about
Over25s:Sam,Lorna,Andrea
E05297535
07-10-2013
Girls.....Hannah, Tamera, Reilly
Boys.....Paul, Paul.....And for the 3rd time Paul
Groups...Miss D, Rough Copy, Next of Kin (maybe)
Overs.....Joseph, lorna, Souli Roots

Nastyman69
07-10-2013
Originally Posted by E05297535:
“Girls.....Hannah, Tamera, Reilly
Boys.....Paul, Paul.....And for the 3rd time Paul
Groups...Miss D, Rough Copy, Next of Kin (maybe)
Overs.....Joseph, lorna, Souli Roots

”

How can I forget about Souli Roots...OK she is in my over 25s in place of Andrea
Stelinz
07-10-2013
Girls - tamera Jade. Melanie
Boys - Paul. Nicholas. ? Maybe Ryan
Overs - Joseph. Sam andrea
Groups - Happy enough with chosen ones although my overall
Fave was next of kin
mangobutter
07-10-2013
Gutted about paul, total mistake there!!!!!!!
carlyxxx
07-10-2013
ill be honest i feel louis and gary are the only judges to have made the correct choices. I now wish sharon had not returned she has picked one good singer and destroyed a good category sam bailey is good to be fair but shelley over joseph what the hell. If i was sharon i would have picked zoe joe and sam but instead she picked 2 similar ladys who will last two weeks no variety at all. Hannah Barrett has no personality at all i feel shes very bland it irritates me nicole keeps saying shes a star no shes not final three girls for me would have been melanie abi lydia. Melanie had th strongest singing voice in the girls category and more likability and personality than hannah. Sharon and Nicole have completly ruined this year. I wish gary got girls nicole over 25s and sharon groups. The only thing thats keeping me watching the s*** is gary as a judge. If i was gary i would have put Steph woods chloe o gorman and 2 other girls in a group.
fireemblemcraze
07-10-2013
Gutted about Melanie, Tom Mann, Joseph, Andrea and Next of Kin not making it.
mangobutter
07-10-2013
Louis made a massive mistake, Gary got it right. Louis should have picked paul, Nicole should have put Melanie in and said no to abi.
Blondie X
07-10-2013
Boys - Paul, Sam, Luke
Girls - Tamera, Hannah, Rellie
Overs - Sam, Lorna, Joseph (though I'd have put through the camp black guy who went at BC)
Groups - Rough Copy, Miss D, Code 4
Kyle123
07-10-2013
Girls: Melanie, Tamera and Hannah
Boys: Paul, Nicholas and umm Luke
Groups: Miss Dynamix, Brick City and Xyra/Rough Copy
Overs: Andrea, Lorna and Sam
mangobutter
07-10-2013
Originally Posted by Kyle123:
“Girls: Melanie, Tamera and Hannah
Boys: Paul, Nicholas and umm Luke
Groups: Miss Dynamix, Brick City and Xyra/Rough Copy
Overs: Andrea, Lorna and Sam”

Yep, I agree with this list. Maybe fit kings land instead of brick
EdgarK
07-10-2013
Girls: Hannah, Tamera, Lydia Lucy
Boys: Tom Mann, Luke, Nicholas
Groups: Miss Dynamix, Xyra, Brick City or Tenors of Rock
Overs: Zoe, Lorna, Sam
pjh8
07-10-2013
Girls- Hannah, Melanie & Tamera
Boys-Luke Sam &Nicholas
Groups- Kingsland Road, Miss Dynamix & Rough Copy
Overs- Joseph, Sam & Zoe
Reality Sucks
07-10-2013
Originally Posted by Kyle123:
“Girls: Melanie, Tamera and Hannah
Boys: Paul, Nicholas and umm Luke
Groups: Miss Dynamix, Brick City and Xyra/Rough Copy
Overs: Andrea, Lorna and Sam”

My list is very similar to yours though I would have still put Abi through over Melanie

Paul was a massive mistake for Louis and Gary shouldn't have put Kingsland Road through.

Mrs O - what a disaster her group is.
CJM91
07-10-2013
I'd have put Giles and Barclay yodeller through instead of Luke and Nicholas. Don't really like Sam either, Giles and yodeller were the best in the boys. Would have put Melanie through instead of Hannah though don't particularly like either. Girl's final 6 not good except tamera and abi.

Gary got it right. Shelley should not have got through over the sexy Joseph either.
LemonadeMouth
07-10-2013
Girls: Melanie.Abi,Jade
Boys: Luke,Paul,Nicholas
Groups: Miss Dynamix, Rough Copy,Brick City
Overs: Andrea,Zoe,Sam
Soppyfan
07-10-2013
Girls: Melanie, Tamera, Abi
Boys: Paul, Sam, Ryan
Groups: XYRA, Brick City, Rough Copy
Overs: Andrea, Sam, Joseph.
Arnold1
08-10-2013
Zoe Devlin instead of Shelley in the Overs.
Paul in the Boys.

Sharon Osborne and Louie are dumbasses who never seem to learn from their past mistakes.
Ryan_Abbott1
08-10-2013
Boys: Paul Akister, Sam Callahan & Nicholas MacDonald
Over's: Sam Bailey, Andrea Magee & Shelley Smith
Groups: Miss Dynamix, Kingsland Road & Xyra
Girls: Hannah Barrett, Melanie McCabe & Jade Richards
EvilLlamaThingy
08-10-2013
Girls - Tamera, Melanie, Abi
Boys - Sam, Nicholas, Paul I guess
Groups - Brick City, Xyra, Miss Dynamix
Overs - Andrea, Sam, Joseph
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map