Originally Posted by dizzie:
“As a Glee fan, I'm convinced that 22-24 episodes for that final season would have managed the same numbers that SQ is hitting...”
You'd also be very wrong.
I think Glee fans tend to forget just how bad its ratings were by the end of its run. Season 6 didn't break a 1 in the demo (Live+SD) once and was comfortably out rated every week by World's Funniest Fails. Its also difficult to argue that this was a side effect of being moved to Friday night. Glee ended its fifth season (on a Tuesday) with a 0.6 in the demo. You have to go back to April 2014 for the last time Glee hit a 1.0 in the demo. And even adding the DVR numbers into the mix doesn't pain a pretty picture. The season five final got a 1.2 with DVR numbers included and the series finale the following year ended with a 1.3 with DVR viewing. So even with DVR viewing its struggling to match what Scream Queens is currently doing Live+SD.
Quote:
“It's pretty widely accepted that Ryan traded his guaranteed season 6 of Glee for an early pick up of SQ. So, Glee got reduced down to a 13 episode final season very late on in negotiations, and SQ was fast tracked through - I suspect to its detriment, because the network didn't pull back on those Ryan Murphy excesses where they just run rampant over SQ's script!”
This isn't really what happened.
Fox wanted out of more episodes of Glee because it had become a commercial and critical disaster by this point. Regardless of whether Murphy leveraged a pick-up for Scream Queens or not there wouldn't have been more episodes of Glee. Fox had actually made it very clear for sometime that they didn't want a full length final season of Glee.
Originally Posted by Jonwo:
“I think Ryan Murphy needs to do something different from AHS and Scream Queens. Given how successful Nip/Tuck was, I wonder why Fox hasn't asked to create a soap opera type show that could be like a sister show to Empire.”
Presumably because they have experience of Glee.
Ryan Murphy simply isn't someone you want involved in writing multi-season television he's terrible at it and he's always been terrible at it. He's like Tim Kring on steroids. He has good ideas but no sense of continuity or development. He can get a good season or two out of a show and then it just implodes in on itself. This is what happened with Nip/Tuck, it happened with Glee and it was happening with Popular before it got canned. Even American Horror Story is somehow collapsing in on itself at this point.