Melanie McCabe to Live Blog First XFactor Live Show

2 of 2

Jessica_Hamby

09-10-2013

Originally Posted by Ronell_Davis:
“Will this girl just go away I'm tired of seeing threads of her when she's out the competition now :yawn:”

You don't have to click on threads with her name on.

jerefprdterra

09-10-2013

How sad for music is that?

fireemblemcraze

09-10-2013

Originally Posted by Ronell_Davis:
“Will this girl just go away I'm tired of seeing threads of her when she's out the competition now :yawn:”

This is an XF forum, Melanie McCabe was in the X Factor and therefore we have every right to talk about her.

I never saw complaints of this multitude when that horrendous Chris was talked about after he was eliminated about how he was robbed. It's ridiculous to see so many complaints about people talking about someone actually quite talented!

s_bowes_uk

09-10-2013

Originally Posted by BodyElectric.:
“It just seems all too desperate in my opinion. She should book gigs, start writing, make some music. She is relatively known by a few people since the show, so gigs shouldn't be a problem.

I don't see the point of this. She's probably going to audition for the 5000000000x again.

She's just so obsessed with the whole XFactor franchise when they've showed they don't care at all about her.”

Bottom line? She can do as she pleases. Simple as that.

essexboyash

09-10-2013

Originally Posted by jerefprdterra:
“I dont think that will be the case.”

You mean you don't want that to be the case

MysteriousOz

09-10-2013

Originally Posted by Wayfarers:
“Surprised at the cynicism levelled at Melanie, she seems a pretty inoffensive harmless character who has a good voice. Why shouldn't she audition for talent shows? She's leagues better than a lot of the atrocities who've been allowed on the X Factor- Wagner, Jedward, Kandy Rain, countless other acts with no singing ability.”

agreed!!!

Eve Elle

10-10-2013

Good for Melanie.

Patti-Ann

10-10-2013

Originally Posted by fireemblemcraze:
“This is an XF forum, Melanie McCabe was in the X Factor and therefore we have every right to talk about her.

I never saw complaints of this multitude when that horrendous Chris was talked about after he was eliminated about how he was robbed. It's ridiculous to see so many complaints about people talking about someone actually quite talented!”

People thought Chris was robbed when he was beaten by James and Jahmene

He did well to get as far as he did

jerefprdterra

10-10-2013

Has she come back yet?

rbdcay

10-10-2013

BIB then you certainly weren't looking hard enough or decided to ignore any thread with his name on it. Chris was almost the most talked about X-factor contestant before and after because he was so laughable.

And Melanie talented...more like middle of the road.

2 of 2