I'd hope for new judges, if the US show were to get axed I would see the panel as
- Simon Cowell
- Demi Lovato
- Mel B
- Robbie Williams
That would be good IMO
- Simon Cowell
- Demi Lovato
- Mel B
- Robbie Williams
That would be good IMO
Nicole also set to leave, Simon to return
2 of 4
Originally Posted by BRITLAND:
“I'd hope for new judges, if the US show were to get axed I would see the panel as
- Simon Cowell
- Demi Lovato
- Mel B
- Robbie Williams
That would be good IMO”
“I'd hope for new judges, if the US show were to get axed I would see the panel as
- Simon Cowell
- Demi Lovato
- Mel B
- Robbie Williams
That would be good IMO”
No to Demi. I do not like her at all. The others would be good, even though I am not a Robbie fan.
Originally Posted by Lucylocket88:
“No to Demi. I do not like her at all. The others would be good, even though I am not a Robbie fan.”
“No to Demi. I do not like her at all. The others would be good, even though I am not a Robbie fan.”
I'm not her biggest fan but she does have brilliant chemistry with Simon & I'm sure the rest of the UK would love her, she also would appeal to the teenage demographic
I wonder if Nicole will perform any of her new songs this year from her new album.
If Nicole leaves then I guess Simon and Cheryl will come back or at least Simon will try to make that happen and if Dannii came back that would be amazing.
If Nicole leaves then I guess Simon and Cheryl will come back or at least Simon will try to make that happen and if Dannii came back that would be amazing.
Simon, Louis, Dannii and Cheryl were the perfect X Factor panel, to me. They had something about them that made you want to watch them as a panel, if that's the right phrasing to use. Just a shame that Simon upped ship to the US, Cheryl got far too big for her boots and followed, and Dannii got sacked, I believe.
On the subject of Nicole, I can't say I'm particularly keen on her, as I find her just a tad too in-your-face - not that there's anything wrong with that; just a little offputting for me. However, despite the fact I find Nicole annoying at times, I hope she stays - she's actually a really good judge from the bits and pieces I've seen of this series. I'd much rather have her on the show than Tulisa, for example, who I simply loathe and found very arrogant and rude on the show, especially last year.
On the subject of Nicole, I can't say I'm particularly keen on her, as I find her just a tad too in-your-face - not that there's anything wrong with that; just a little offputting for me. However, despite the fact I find Nicole annoying at times, I hope she stays - she's actually a really good judge from the bits and pieces I've seen of this series. I'd much rather have her on the show than Tulisa, for example, who I simply loathe and found very arrogant and rude on the show, especially last year.
I cannot understand the excitement over the prospect of Cheryl and Danni returning, I think Cheryl's become really arrogant and bigheaded, and her solo career isn't huge anymore, and Danni I found quite dull and bitchy at times, luckily I think Danni is loyal to the Australian version so I can't see her coming back! It'd be a huge shame to see the back of Nicole.
Originally Posted by d56:
“Louis will stay if Simon comes back. Hopefully Nicole will too.
It wouldn't surprise me if Cheryl returned, just like Jlo on American Idol, they need these shows to sell their music.”
“Louis will stay if Simon comes back. Hopefully Nicole will too.
It wouldn't surprise me if Cheryl returned, just like Jlo on American Idol, they need these shows to sell their music.”
Cheryl is completely pathetic, she would do anything to revive her Music Career. It wouldn't surprise me if she did come back next year...
I didn't believe her for one second when she kept insisting she's done with the show.:yawn:I can see Simon bringing Demi over to the UK. Nicole, Demi, Simon and Louis would be an interesting panel.
Originally Posted by casualtyno1fan:
“Simon, Louis, Dannii and Cheryl were the perfect X Factor panel, to me. They had something about them that made you want to watch them as a panel, if that's the right phrasing to use. Just a shame that Simon upped ship to the US, Cheryl got far too big for her boots and followed, and Dannii got sacked, I believe.
On the subject of Nicole, I can't say I'm particularly keen on her, as I find her just a tad too in-your-face - not that there's anything wrong with that; just a little offputting for me. However, despite the fact I find Nicole annoying at times, I hope she stays - she's actually a really good judge from the bits and pieces I've seen of this series. I'd much rather have her on the show than Tulisa, for example, who I simply loathe and found very arrogant and rude on the show, especially last year.”
“Simon, Louis, Dannii and Cheryl were the perfect X Factor panel, to me. They had something about them that made you want to watch them as a panel, if that's the right phrasing to use. Just a shame that Simon upped ship to the US, Cheryl got far too big for her boots and followed, and Dannii got sacked, I believe.
On the subject of Nicole, I can't say I'm particularly keen on her, as I find her just a tad too in-your-face - not that there's anything wrong with that; just a little offputting for me. However, despite the fact I find Nicole annoying at times, I hope she stays - she's actually a really good judge from the bits and pieces I've seen of this series. I'd much rather have her on the show than Tulisa, for example, who I simply loathe and found very arrogant and rude on the show, especially last year.”
Dannii wasn't sacked. She chose not to do it, because it meant fyling back and forward between London and Australia, due to her taking part in 'Australia's Got Talent at the time. She did not want to do this, because it wasn't fair on her kid, who was still a young baby at the time.
I'd like Nicole to stay, I think producers will try hard to convince her to stay if all 3 others are leaving. They'll want at least one to remain the same.
I think if x factor us doesn't continue next year Simon will be back and I think he'll bring Demi with him.
I think if x factor us doesn't continue next year Simon will be back and I think he'll bring Demi with him.
Never got the Cheryl love. I found her a complete bore as a judge with her insightful comments such as 'you look like a little pop star' or 'that was really good pet'.
I really think bringing her back would be a mistake
I really think bringing her back would be a mistake
If Simon comes back he'll bring Cheryl back. Then Louis will stay.
Dannii will be the interesting one. If Kylie and the new format voice works then having the a Minogue back on X Factor will excite Simon, as he'll see it as adding rivalry
Dannii will be the interesting one. If Kylie and the new format voice works then having the a Minogue back on X Factor will excite Simon, as he'll see it as adding rivalry
Originally Posted by Isleepinthebuff:
“If Simon comes back he'll bring Cheryl back. Then Louis will stay.
Dannii will be the interesting one. If Kylie and the new format voice works then having the a Minogue back on X Factor will excite Simon, as he'll see it as adding rivalry”
“If Simon comes back he'll bring Cheryl back. Then Louis will stay.
Dannii will be the interesting one. If Kylie and the new format voice works then having the a Minogue back on X Factor will excite Simon, as he'll see it as adding rivalry”
Dannii is on the aussie version now. I think she will be back on the Australian version next year. I just cannot see her going back to the UK show. Four series on the UK version may have been enough for her.
Originally Posted by JustArun:
“Cheryl is completely pathetic, she would do anything to revive her Music Career. It wouldn't surprise me if she did come back next year... I didn't believe her for one second when she kept insisting she's done with the show.:yawn:
I can see Simon bringing Demi over to the UK. Nicole, Demi, Simon and Louis would be an interesting panel.”
“Cheryl is completely pathetic, she would do anything to revive her Music Career. It wouldn't surprise me if she did come back next year...
I didn't believe her for one second when she kept insisting she's done with the show.:yawn:I can see Simon bringing Demi over to the UK. Nicole, Demi, Simon and Louis would be an interesting panel.
”
Exactly, she needs the show. There isn't interest in her now like there was and she has no Girls Aloud to fall back on.
If XF USA ends and Simon returns, I think he'd be more likely to try and bring back Kelly than bring Demi over!
In all honestly, they need to axe the show now, it's just getting worse and worse!
In all honestly, they need to axe the show now, it's just getting worse and worse!
Looks like the whole panel is leaving. Simon will be back, which is good. I won't watch it if Cheryl comes back but I doubt if she will
Originally Posted by d56:
“Exactly, she needs the show. There isn't interest in her now like there was and she has no Girls Aloud to fall back on.”
“Exactly, she needs the show. There isn't interest in her now like there was and she has no Girls Aloud to fall back on.”
Cheryl doesn't need the show. The show needs her. She may actually get more satisfaction watching the show sink into oblivian knowing the ratings were far higher when she was a judge.
Cheryl is just completely bitter and lacks class. Nicole upstaged her without even trying.
Quote:
“ "I adore Cheryl, she’s gorgeous." - Nicole
"I don’t know if she could [go solo]…I don’t think she stands out as amazing at all" + “She’s crazy and odd. I swear to God the woman sang the whole song, to my face. It was just so awkward.” - Cheryl
"What I read didn’t seem like it was written to make me look very well. But I never know what to believe. I’d like to give her the benefit of the doubt and hope that she would only have spoken highly of me because I’ve not spoken poorly of her." - Nicole”
“ "I adore Cheryl, she’s gorgeous." - Nicole
"I don’t know if she could [go solo]…I don’t think she stands out as amazing at all" + “She’s crazy and odd. I swear to God the woman sang the whole song, to my face. It was just so awkward.” - Cheryl
"What I read didn’t seem like it was written to make me look very well. But I never know what to believe. I’d like to give her the benefit of the doubt and hope that she would only have spoken highly of me because I’ve not spoken poorly of her." - Nicole”
Originally Posted by JustArun:
“Cheryl is just completely bitter and lacks class. Nicole upstaged her without even trying.”
“Cheryl is just completely bitter and lacks class. Nicole upstaged her without even trying.
”
I think Nicole threatens Cheryl. Cheryl is attractive and can dance, but she cannot sing and lacks charisma and the likeable factor in my opinion. I thought she was the most bland judge the show has had. She is a good mentor though.
Nicole on the other hand, is attractive, can sing and dance, has charisma and the likeable factor. She is also a more interesting judge in my opinion and a good mentor.
Give me Nicole as a judge on the show over Cheryl any day.
Originally Posted by Lucylocket88:
“I think Nicole threatens Cheryl. Cheryl is attractive and can dance, but she cannot sing and lacks charisma and the likeable factor in my opinion. I thought she was the most bland judge the show has had. She is a good mentor though.
Nicole on the other hand, is attractive, can sing and dance, has charisma and the likeable factor. She is also a more interesting judge in my opinion and a good mentor.
Give me Nicole as a judge on the show over Cheryl any day.”
“I think Nicole threatens Cheryl. Cheryl is attractive and can dance, but she cannot sing and lacks charisma and the likeable factor in my opinion. I thought she was the most bland judge the show has had. She is a good mentor though.
Nicole on the other hand, is attractive, can sing and dance, has charisma and the likeable factor. She is also a more interesting judge in my opinion and a good mentor.
Give me Nicole as a judge on the show over Cheryl any day.”
Exactly. Well put.
Originally Posted by JustArun:
“Cheryl is just completely bitter and lacks class. Nicole upstaged her without even trying.”
“Cheryl is just completely bitter and lacks class. Nicole upstaged her without even trying.
”
I have to re-post what someone wrote on another site because it's so true
Quote:
“Whatever Cheryl does, Nicole does it better.
Cheryl's audition in Popstars VS Nicole's standout audition in Popstars
Cheryl's basic spot in Girls Aloud VS Nicole's leading role in PCD
Cheryl's "dance" with Derek Hough VS Nicole's critically acclaimed win in Dancing With The Starts with Derek Hough
Cheryl's 1 and a half episode on X Factor US VS Nicole taking over her judging spot
Cheryl's mentoring on X Factor( we all know how she is with her contestants after the show has ended) VS Nicole's incredible mentoring on X Factor( still friends with everyone, still supports them)
Cheryl's 3-4 years on X Factor UK VS Nicole's first year on the X Factor UK, breaking records with all her boys in the Top 5.
Cheryl's performances( let me NOT at how many times she was slammed for miming) VS Nicole's energizing LIVE performances
Cheryl's voice VS Nicole's voice
Cheryl praised by the likes of Katy Perry and Rihanna as to how hot she is VS Nicole praised by legends like Andrew Lloyd Webber, Sting, Alice Cooper, Stever Tyler for her vocal talents.
Cheryl's laughable performance with Gary Barlow VS Nicole's incredible performance with Gary Barlow.”
“Whatever Cheryl does, Nicole does it better.
Cheryl's audition in Popstars VS Nicole's standout audition in Popstars
Cheryl's basic spot in Girls Aloud VS Nicole's leading role in PCD
Cheryl's "dance" with Derek Hough VS Nicole's critically acclaimed win in Dancing With The Starts with Derek Hough
Cheryl's 1 and a half episode on X Factor US VS Nicole taking over her judging spot
Cheryl's mentoring on X Factor( we all know how she is with her contestants after the show has ended) VS Nicole's incredible mentoring on X Factor( still friends with everyone, still supports them)
Cheryl's 3-4 years on X Factor UK VS Nicole's first year on the X Factor UK, breaking records with all her boys in the Top 5.
Cheryl's performances( let me NOT at how many times she was slammed for miming) VS Nicole's energizing LIVE performances
Cheryl's voice VS Nicole's voice
Cheryl praised by the likes of Katy Perry and Rihanna as to how hot she is VS Nicole praised by legends like Andrew Lloyd Webber, Sting, Alice Cooper, Stever Tyler for her vocal talents.
Cheryl's laughable performance with Gary Barlow VS Nicole's incredible performance with Gary Barlow.”
Originally Posted by JustArun:
“Cheryl is just completely bitter and lacks class. Nicole upstaged her without even trying.”
“Cheryl is just completely bitter and lacks class. Nicole upstaged her without even trying.
”
I like Nicole but she is a manipulator. Cheryl may have a point and seen through the manipulations and may have merely reported the truth of what she saw. I have noticed some odd things about Nicole myself but I do still like her.
Originally Posted by JustArun:
“Cheryl is just completely bitter and lacks class. Nicole upstaged her without even trying.”
“Cheryl is just completely bitter and lacks class. Nicole upstaged her without even trying.
”
A million percent completely agree with you Arun
2 of 4
