Nicole also set to leave, Simon to return

3 of 4

JustArun

13-10-2013

Originally Posted by Arnold1:
“I like Nicole but she is a manipulator. Cheryl may have a point and seen through the manipulations and may have merely reported the truth of what she saw. I have noticed some odd things about Nicole myself but I do still like her.”

She isn't manipulating anyone. Nicole sang her song because she liked it...she was trying to show Cheryl that she loves Cheryl's Music. Cheryl was just bitter that Nicole took the song to places Cheryl couldn't.

Angel Dust

13-10-2013

Originally Posted by Lucylocket88:
“I think Nicole threatens Cheryl. Cheryl is attractive and can dance, but she cannot sing and lacks charisma and the likeable factor in my opinion. I thought she was the most bland judge the show has had. She is a good mentor though.

Nicole on the other hand, is attractive, can sing and dance, has charisma and the likeable factor. She is also a more interesting judge in my opinion and a good mentor.

Give me Nicole as a judge on the show over Cheryl any day.”

I agree. Cheryl was just a pretty face with nothing behind the eyes. Nicole is far more attractive and sexy imo and is also funnier, more vibrant, more talented and more charismatic.

cah

13-10-2013

I've never liked Nicole much so would be happy to see her go .Would love to see a Simon and Cheryl return and for Sharon and Louis to stay

mysty211

13-10-2013

I think Nicole and Cheryl could come to an agreement they didn't actually fall out so maybe if Simon did have them both they'd get along as they don't really know each other yet. But then they are both pretty they might be both wanting to have the best outfit of the night.

Arnold1

13-10-2013

Originally Posted by JustArun:
“She isn't manipulating anyone. Nicole sang her song because she liked it...she was trying to show Cheryl that she loves Cheryl's Music. Cheryl was just bitter that Nicole took the song to places Cheryl couldn't.”

You can't know for sure what's going on in someone's mind so we can only speculate.

JordyD

13-10-2013

They have to go ahead with next years show, as it's the 10th Anniversary.

I think the best panel they could hope for next year is Simon, Sharon, Louis, and Cheryl. It may then bow out or continue if ratings improve.

LW09

13-10-2013

Looks like next year will be Simon, Cheryl and Louis with Mel B or Kelly Rowland in the fourth spot.

Convict

13-10-2013

Nicole should stay. She is much better than Cheryl ever was.

gilliedew

13-10-2013

I love watching Nicole since her PC days, She was brilliant last year but she is so subdued this and looks as if she is still breaking her heart over Lewis. She is only about half as enthusiastic as she one was and has got alarmingly thin but still breathtakingly beautiful.

That Lewis is an idiot, I hope they get back together to bring our Nicole back on song and shcurmazing again, if not, she should leave and take time out to feel stronger and meet someone worthy of her.

paperplanes_

13-10-2013

Oh I like Nicole.

Dave0893

13-10-2013

My ideal panel would be Simon, Cheryl, Nicole and Louis.

Simon and Louis' banter was great, Simon and Cheryl had great chemistry, Louis and Nicole had great chemistry aswell, Louis and Cheryl have quite a fiery relationship and the whole Cheryl/Nicole angle would create press, though I'd like to see them just get on and be mature.

Julie_Evans

13-10-2013

Originally Posted by Lucylocket88:
“I think Nicole threatens Cheryl. Cheryl is attractive and can dance, but she cannot sing and lacks charisma and the likeable factor in my opinion. I thought she was the most bland judge the show has had. She is a good mentor though.

Nicole on the other hand, is attractive, can sing and dance, has charisma and the likeable factor. She is also a more interesting judge in my opinion and a good mentor.

Give me Nicole as a judge on the show over Cheryl any day.”

BIB - Totally disagree. No-one is blander than Gary, and Tulisa was far worse than Cheryl.

fireemblemcraze

13-10-2013

Originally Posted by Reserved:
“Something I don't like about Nicole. Can't quite put my finger on what it is about her...

I'll be happy if all the judges go. It'd be like a fresh start for a fresh decade. Somehow, I don't see Louis going anywhere, though ”

Don't really understand these comments so you basically don't like Nicole for no reason in particular? Thanks for sharing that with us. She is wonderfully energetic and sweet so this sort of comment where you can't actually find fault her but dislike her anyway really puts me off.

conchie

13-10-2013

Originally Posted by Dave0893:
“My ideal panel would be Simon, Cheryl, Nicole and Louis.

Simon and Louis' banter was great, Simon and Cheryl had great chemistry, Louis and Nicole had great chemistry aswell, Louis and Cheryl have quite a fiery relationship and the whole Cheryl/Nicole angle would create press, though I'd like to see them just get on and be mature.”

Sounds about perfect. Agree with all your points.

Cosya

13-10-2013

The crap judge that is Walsh will now stay

Archangel

14-10-2013

It'll never happen but I'd like to see Simon, Dannii, Kylie & Robbie (without the ego).

InMyArms

14-10-2013

News of her leaving originates in the Daily Star.. so lets all assume the opposite to be true.

summerbunny

14-10-2013

Originally Posted by casualtyno1fan:
“Simon, Louis, Dannii and Cheryl were the perfect X Factor panel, to me. They had something about them that made you want to watch them as a panel, if that's the right phrasing to use. Just a shame that Simon upped ship to the US, Cheryl got far too big for her boots and followed, and Dannii got sacked, I believe.

On the subject of Nicole, I can't say I'm particularly keen on her, as I find her just a tad too in-your-face - not that there's anything wrong with that; just a little offputting for me. However, despite the fact I find Nicole annoying at times, I hope she stays - she's actually a really good judge from the bits and pieces I've seen of this series. I'd much rather have her on the show than Tulisa, for example, who I simply loathe and found very arrogant and rude on the show, especially last year.”

I agree Simon, Louis, Dannii and Cheryl were the perfect panel

I don't like Nicole she just gets on my nerves so pleased to here she's not back next year.

If they can't get tbe panel right for next year to I really think they should call it a day.
Simon needs to came back theres no way Cheryl will ever came back and Simon won't have tulisa again.

mysty211

14-10-2013

I'm thinking Simon , Will.I.Am , Cheryl , Dannii might be a good panel.

summerbunny

14-10-2013

Originally Posted by mysty211:
“I'm thinking Simon , Will.I.Am , Cheryl , Dannii might be a good panel.”

Dannii won't be back she is fully committed to Australia's xfactor and after the whole affair with Simon thing it just won't happen.

I'd be amazed if Cheryl ever returned she hates Simon and has a lawsuit on tbe xfactor brand.

RussJ

14-10-2013

I hope she doesn't go, it's enough losing Gary, I really like the panel this year.

Dinno

14-10-2013

I want tulisa back for next year.

Dave0893

14-10-2013

Originally Posted by InMyArms:
“News of her leaving originates in the Daily Star.. so lets all assume the opposite to be true.”

I thought I read it came from Sharon's book?

Originally Posted by summerbunny:
“Dannii won't be back she is fully committed to Australia's xfactor and after the whole affair with Simon thing it just won't happen.

I'd be amazed if Cheryl ever returned she hates Simon and has a lawsuit on tbe xfactor brand.”

She doesn't hate Simon, they have both said they are friends again and Cheryl isn't suing X Factor, she is suing the production company in the US. Plus she happily returned to be a guest mentor at judges home last year, so she can't hate Simon or the show that much.

NicoleRich

14-10-2013

ew if Cheryl returns that it im out. Nicole is the best judge, such a sweetheart and such a wonderful beauty to watch on tv.

abrightyz

14-10-2013

nicole and louis should stay... i hope these are only in view of a pay rise for both...

3 of 4