Originally Posted by
Pizzatheaction:
“I'm surprised at how well Strictly Come Dancing held up against the football, particularly as the football kicked off well before SCD started. Even more surprised when you consider the unusually warm weather might have tempted a few people out for the early evening.
I think BBC One can relax over Merlin now. It seems it will deliver Robin Hood sized audiences throughout the autumn.
It's a bit of a worry that they now only have one popular lottery format (In It To Win It), though, and Casualty is a bit jaded now. You also have to question the wisdom of a one-day-later narrative repeat in primetime.
I made my annual toe-dip into The X Factor last night, when I watched the results show, except the very end (Which girl group got knocked out?)
I wanted to see how strong the last twelve acts were. I'd say nine were good, two more were okay, and one made me laugh out loud! Strangly, the one I thought worst actually avoided being in the bottom two.
”
Good post & I agree with it all.
Yes, BBC1 seem to have found a solid hit in Merlin, which is pulling in Robin Hood/Primeval style figures.
I'm sure Casualty held up better than this against XF last year & it does seem to show weakening signs. Personally I think it's not as good as it used to be. It needs a longer break than 1 month aswell imo.
Also I really can't see the theory behind showing effectively an import in virtually the same primetime slot 2 days a week
Personally I thought most of the XF acts were rubbish to put it nicely, there were some which shone out, but I can't understand why people think this years selection is so much better. After the poor quality last night I can see a drop off next week, following interest at the beginning.
Also probably not for here but the XF is turning into a drama big style-DEADLOCK last night made me LOL

The way the set changed was hilarious and I even heard some of the audience laughing. What's the betting in next week they say at the beginning ''over 11 million of you watched last week-the biggest show of the day by milliooonnnns!!''