Originally Posted by Ms_Sarah:
“I just watched S6 E2 on my PBS station. Why must they continue this awkward attempt to denigrate the personal character of Louisa. The Doc examines her and finds dandruff (she doesn't wash or rinse enough, apparently) and tells her that he normally sees this in women half her age. Ugh.
(bad breath, snores, can't dance, disorganized, untidy, poor personal hygeine)
Really?
The writing is weirdly skewed, imo.
Little men - little minds.”
Not to mention having difficulty controlling the kids at her school, too fond of sugar, jealous of her babysitter, shrewish to her husband, short-tempered, and even needing instruction in cooking (as he explains to her a better way to cook asparagus.)
I think you're on to something. I do think the treatment of Louisa is somewhat skewed. It's not that Martin is portrayed without faults -- but his faults are mostly heroic rather than petty, and when he's rude, at least he's telling the truth, etc.
Notice also that we see much less of Louisa's point of view. I'd guess the reaction shots of him, or scenes where he's filmed alone, looking mournful or confused, are about twice as many as Louisa gets. I think this generates a lot of sympathy for him. This clearly has to do with the series being a vehicle for MC.
We in the audience know a lot about his feelings and intentions, which are hidden from Louisa, but by the same token, we really don't know a lot about what is driving Louisa.
As an old survey researcher, I like to quantify things in this way, but I would bet that the ratio of Louisa critics to Martin critics is about two - to - one. Which I do think reflects the skewing.