Originally Posted by NewPark:
“My take on that scene is a little different, and I'm sure there are many different "takes" on it b/c it's not really clear what's going on.
I think it's pretty clear why he didn't take the opportunities Louisa offered him to get off the hook --he just didn't want to admit that he wasn't up to it. But he really didn't want to do it, and sometimes when people are stuck doing something they don't want to do, their behavior does become rather "passive-aggressive." And that's what I originally thought he was doing.
But after mulling it over, I'm not so sure. I think the scene really divides into two parts. In the first one, he is contradicting Louisa about the value of athletics and exercise. Just previous to this, he had reminded his mother that all he had won at school was a cup for chess. So, I think in this part, the unathletic and probably jeered at schoolboy was speaking out in defense of himself.
In the second part, his behavior becomes almost demented -- in his haste to get away and back to the surgery. I think he is frightened by the extent to which he is unraveling and needs to get back to the safety of his surgery and inside his own head, to quell his growing anxiety. It almost looks like a panic attack. At any rate, he is clearly out of control.
.....omitted rest.....”
Agree in part and in part not, NewPark. My second viewing found me watching it more dispassionately and this is what I saw and interpreted:
[LIST][*]DM is taking his pulse as he arrives at sports day and as usual is oblivious to children around him.[/LIST][LIST][*]He asks LGE as soon as he arrives "will it take long because I couldn't cancel all my patients and don't have that much time at all."[/LIST][LIST][*]LGE responds it will take a bit more time (10 min.), he agrees he can stay, and then as she introduces him, he tells her twice quietly that he doesn't have time
to speak. He agreed to give out "prizes".[/LIST][LIST][*]She insists on trying to get him to and he is truthful-Doc when he says there can be injuries.[/LIST][LIST][*]Then, yes, he does channel chess-playing-Doc, telling his own truth as well. (Brilliant the reference back to his previously mentioned winning of a "silver jug" for chess.)[/LIST][LIST][*]He gives out medals but when the announcer says "whole school...." is when he says he "doesn't have time (
yet again), give me the medals, you hand out the cups....." (
Taking over and trying to work an efficient system to still do what he said he would--give out medals.)[/LIST][LIST][*]And then LGE loses it. Because he is not doing the ceremony the way she envisions it for her students.[/LIST][LIST][*]He just needs to get back to the surgery for his patients.[/LIST]I don't see him as panicking or demented there. He seems in control of himself, trying to do what he said he would do, but trying to keep to his timetable of patients. I just simply believe him when he says over and over that he doesn't have time. He is a punctual man.
LGE says in the morning that he will be their special guest, give the awards. Did they have a more complete conversation before that where her expectations for what that meant were enumerated?
We see his unhinging in his forgetting that it was sports day, his lack of sleep, weight-loss, his not dealing with Dad's death, not being happy Mummy is there, etc. Otherwise he is still functioning at his job. He can do that.
But then the accident. He can't help but probably blame himself for Louisa's getting hurt ('If I hadn't hurried away so fast...'), but the blow of her going away, needing a break from him--that's cause for him to feel worse, all by itself.
(I do empathize with LGE for wanting to go on a little vacation, even just a weekend. That was always my first thought on school holidays myself, even as a teacher.)