Originally Posted by Mofromco:
“The medical veracity in the episode was seriously lacking so the next time you are in an Operating Theatre do not imitate what you saw in the scenes. It doesn't bother me because when watching TV, movies etc. it becomes very clear to me whether to take the presentation as realistic or not. The OR dramatization of sclerosing Louisa's AVM was totally bogus. He touched Louisa's cheek which broke scrub...he must have pulled his mask down to barf and went back to the table..which broke scrub. I would have thought her head would have been immobilized because threading the catheter through blood vessels would be exacting work. Maybe it would be SOP for the patient to go home so soon after that surgery..I'm not a surgeon..but I wouldn't want MY patient to go home that soon. So..in a word..it was a bogus representation all the way around.
(I wonder if they broke the medical show law? That Martin..he's so funny)”
Originally Posted by conchie:
“As if a doctor, surgeon or NOT, who has not operated in a few years would A. be allowed just walk into the theatre of a hospital where he is not even on staff B. proceed to perform a delicate and dangerous procedure while suffering a blood phobia, and C... perform it on his WIFE !!! I won't even elaborate on just puking up in the corner of theatre and returning to the table, not as much as a change of mask, never mind re-scrubbing !!
I work for a Surgeon, and let me tell you this is actually bordering on science fiction !!”
Originally Posted by mmDerdekea:
“The dashing about did elevate my adrenaline and it was interesting to have DM do the surgery, which has already been noted would not be okay, (nor is it okay to lock someone in a closet and apparently have no one notice that someone is, no doubt, pounding and screeching to be let out right by the surgical theatre). Plus, having had brain surgery, after the prepatory Versed injection (or the British equivalent) you really cannot hold any type of real conversation and yes, LG would remember none of it. Unless, there is a PW effect floating around Truro Hospital!
I hope others agree this finale was enjoyable.”
I admit I got a chuckle in the middle of all of the tense medical events as I watched E8 because I couldn't get MC's statement that by law in the UK medical shows must be accurate, unlike in the US where they "make things up". I'm not a medical professional and even I could see that some of what took place was bizarre and no way could it happen in reality. Funny description, conchie, that it bordered on science fiction.
It started with my question of how on earth did Martin end up about to assist the surgeon. And then how could the surgeon be so incompetent? And then how could the others in the operating room just simply accept DM's statement that he will perform the surgery? Aren't they thinking, "Who in the heck is this guy, especially when he then proceeds to walk up to the patient and start a conversation with her which clearly indicates he's her husband?
But, like many of us, I happily suspended my disbelief as I enjoyed the episode so much. There's been a theme running through this show that is finally being addressed. Is it possible for people to change? We've heard both AJ and AR (and others too, I think) say people can't change. Now AR says Martin can change, but it will take hard work, and finally he appears ready to face the reality that he
needs to change. I couldn't help but think of his attempt in S3 to be friendly and nice, but he ended up being "smarmy", at least in Louisa's opinion. I've been waiting all this time for him to ask for her help. I think NewPark mentioned this too, that finally we got to hear the speech we've been waiting for.