Originally Posted by Bloodphobia:
“New Park. Please tell us more. You have always been a good observer and analyst of the show. I am still grappling with my feelings about S6 and your insight would help. Thank you”
I think my feelings about this won't be very edifying -- in fact, I think they're quite childish.
From the moment I read MC's off-hand remark that, since they had a child together, DM and LE would have a relationship, even if they weren't a couple, I started dreading what I was pretty sure was going to happen, in S6. That is, a long down-hill slide into pain and misery for both, followed by a two year waiting period to see how and if they resolved things so that they were once more a couple.
I think the odds are that they will resolve things mostly positively, basically for the reason that it just would not be a good business decision to do otherwise. And also, I strongly feel that it would make nonsense of all that has gone before. But I think a part of MC flirts with the idea of proving once and for all that this is not a "cosy" show, and choosing the edgy, painful ending over the comforting one. I can imagine that the way this tension might be resolved is to end S7 on a hopeful, but still somewhat ambiguous, note. So I don't entirely trust BP in this respect.
I know that, with some lapses,it was artistically done, and beautifully acted. Also, I do think DM's downhill path, and LE's inability to understand or deal with what was happening, are quite plausible really, given their general levels of emotional maturity and dysfunction. And a friend has just emailed me with a comment very similar to the one that triggered my post == that when she watched the series originally, episode by episode, she was still seeing it through the veil of all the pleasant scenarios her imagination had built up over the last couple of years, and on first watching, was disappointed. But then, watching it as one piece and knowing the ending, she liked it much better. She also believes, though, that the ending strongly points to a positive resolution in S7. And I understand that point and am glad that is the case for some people.
Still, all that being said, I guess I just feel that there are a number of alternate Portwenn universes, in which different and less painful, but still entertaining, scenarios might have played out. Did they really have to go right to the one that would inflict maximum pain to their characters and viewers (well, OK, they didn't kill Louisa off, as some feared). I feel that it was more than a little manipulative, but then, I also understand that's the name of the game in good drama -- to hook people and keep them dangling as long as possible!
I don't even want to think about what weakness in me that it reveals, but I get way too caught up in this narrative, and probably have way too much sympathy for each of them, and so I just found it very, very painful to watch, and I'm not sure I want to put myself through that again, at least without being convinced that ultimately, they will come through this in a stronger and better relationship.